007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support

Elfriede I. Krauth, Jos van Hillegersberg, Steef L. van de Velde

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

Abstract

Adoption rates of traditional Operations Research (OR) based decision support systems (DSS) suffer from perceived complexity of the underlying model and its detrimental effect on user-friendliness. The mental effort required to understand abstract models can hinder adoption. This barrier may seem even greater to people with low analytic capabilities. Unfortunately it is often this user group that could benefit the most from using OR based DSS. Agent based approaches on the other hand typically model negotiations between real-world counterparts. Extending cognitive fit theory we argue that presenting DSS in an agent based fashion allows for a closer match between the model presented on screen and the mental model of the user. We tested the impact of DSS presentation on perceived usefulness in a lab experiment (n=118). Our data suggests that an agent presentation outperforms an OR based DSS for perceived usefulness for low analytic users.
Original languageUndefined
Number of pages1
Publication statusPublished - 2007
Event6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007 - Montreal, Canada
Duration: 8 Dec 20078 Dec 2007
Conference number: 6

Workshop

Workshop6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007
Abbreviated titleHCI/MIS
CountryCanada
CityMontreal
Period8/12/078/12/07

Keywords

  • Cognitive fit
  • Agent Technology
  • IR-78003
  • decision support systems for transport problems

Cite this

Krauth, E. I., van Hillegersberg, J., & van de Velde, S. L. (2007). 007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support. Paper presented at 6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007, Montreal, Canada.
Krauth, Elfriede I. ; van Hillegersberg, Jos ; van de Velde, Steef L. / 007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support. Paper presented at 6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007, Montreal, Canada.1 p.
@conference{81e92a4153294be18247737c5a29afae,
title = "007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support",
abstract = "Adoption rates of traditional Operations Research (OR) based decision support systems (DSS) suffer from perceived complexity of the underlying model and its detrimental effect on user-friendliness. The mental effort required to understand abstract models can hinder adoption. This barrier may seem even greater to people with low analytic capabilities. Unfortunately it is often this user group that could benefit the most from using OR based DSS. Agent based approaches on the other hand typically model negotiations between real-world counterparts. Extending cognitive fit theory we argue that presenting DSS in an agent based fashion allows for a closer match between the model presented on screen and the mental model of the user. We tested the impact of DSS presentation on perceived usefulness in a lab experiment (n=118). Our data suggests that an agent presentation outperforms an OR based DSS for perceived usefulness for low analytic users.",
keywords = "Cognitive fit, Agent Technology, IR-78003, decision support systems for transport problems",
author = "Krauth, {Elfriede I.} and {van Hillegersberg}, Jos and {van de Velde}, {Steef L.}",
year = "2007",
language = "Undefined",
note = "null ; Conference date: 08-12-2007 Through 08-12-2007",

}

Krauth, EI, van Hillegersberg, J & van de Velde, SL 2007, '007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support' Paper presented at 6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007, Montreal, Canada, 8/12/07 - 8/12/07, .

007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support. / Krauth, Elfriede I.; van Hillegersberg, Jos; van de Velde, Steef L.

2007. Paper presented at 6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007, Montreal, Canada.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademic

TY - CONF

T1 - 007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support

AU - Krauth, Elfriede I.

AU - van Hillegersberg, Jos

AU - van de Velde, Steef L.

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - Adoption rates of traditional Operations Research (OR) based decision support systems (DSS) suffer from perceived complexity of the underlying model and its detrimental effect on user-friendliness. The mental effort required to understand abstract models can hinder adoption. This barrier may seem even greater to people with low analytic capabilities. Unfortunately it is often this user group that could benefit the most from using OR based DSS. Agent based approaches on the other hand typically model negotiations between real-world counterparts. Extending cognitive fit theory we argue that presenting DSS in an agent based fashion allows for a closer match between the model presented on screen and the mental model of the user. We tested the impact of DSS presentation on perceived usefulness in a lab experiment (n=118). Our data suggests that an agent presentation outperforms an OR based DSS for perceived usefulness for low analytic users.

AB - Adoption rates of traditional Operations Research (OR) based decision support systems (DSS) suffer from perceived complexity of the underlying model and its detrimental effect on user-friendliness. The mental effort required to understand abstract models can hinder adoption. This barrier may seem even greater to people with low analytic capabilities. Unfortunately it is often this user group that could benefit the most from using OR based DSS. Agent based approaches on the other hand typically model negotiations between real-world counterparts. Extending cognitive fit theory we argue that presenting DSS in an agent based fashion allows for a closer match between the model presented on screen and the mental model of the user. We tested the impact of DSS presentation on perceived usefulness in a lab experiment (n=118). Our data suggests that an agent presentation outperforms an OR based DSS for perceived usefulness for low analytic users.

KW - Cognitive fit

KW - Agent Technology

KW - IR-78003

KW - decision support systems for transport problems

M3 - Paper

ER -

Krauth EI, van Hillegersberg J, van de Velde SL. 007 to the Rescue – Cognitive Fit of Operations Research and Agent-based Decision Support. 2007. Paper presented at 6th Pre-ICIS Annual Workshop on HCI Research in MIS, HCI/MIS 2007, Montreal, Canada.