A comparison of the effectiveness of incentives and directives: the case of Dutch water quality policy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademic

19 Citations (Scopus)
99 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The use of effluent charges as an instrument o f regulatory policy has been the object of much dispute. The controversy between advocates and opponents of replacing directives by incentive strategies in various fields of public intervention has always been rather heated, though carried on more in terms of theory than of empirical evidence drawn from experience with policy instruments in actual operation. Much like permit trading in the United States, regulatory effluent charges in The Netherlands more or less "sneaked in through the back door." The Dutch system o f water quality charges had originally been designed to fulfill solely a revenue-raising function. The unique features of The Netherlands system make it an interesting example of the use of charges. The Dutch system of effluent charges has been in operation since 1970 and, in terms of the level of the charges, is more than twice as large as the more recent German program. Furthermore its use as a regulatory instrument has been "accidental." It did not replace the official intervention strategy of direct regulation. Given this situation, the Dutch case provides a unique opportunity to examine the effects of these two approaches as they were applied to the same case. Three statistical analyses of the impacts of the policy instrument used, supplemented by two expert assessments of these impacts, show the Dutch effluent charges have had a very remarkable effect on industrial polluters. In Holland, t h e water quality policy i s regarded as one of t h e few examples o f successful governmental intervention. The final section presents some general thoughts on relevance of the Dutch experience with effluent charges for other countries.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)500-518
JournalPolicy Studies Review
Volume7
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1988

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'A comparison of the effectiveness of incentives and directives: the case of Dutch water quality policy'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this