Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance

Sergio Manrique*, Emili Grifell-Tatjé

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Working paper

24 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Collaboration between universities and firms has boosted worldwide, due to the transition towards open business models on the industry side and the development of universities’ third mission on the academia side. Such collaboration is expected to contribute positively to the improvement and development of products and practices at firms, which should lead to better corporate financial performance. We argue that these financial benefits should be the major motivation form firms to ‘open’ their R&D activities and interact with universities. Despite there is a broad literature on the determinants of university-firm collaboration (UFC) and its effects on R&D and innovation processes at firms, the study of its impact on corporate financial performance, especially in empirical terms, remains unexplored. This paper attempts to assess the impact of UFC on the corporate financial performance related to firm innovation efforts. To do so, we isolate the innovation-related inputs used by firms to produce radically and incrementally innovative products, and compare the innovation-related profitability of collaborating and non-collaborating firms with a benchmarking model based on Empirical Index Numbers (EINs) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) efficiency measures for a sample of 1,060 observations from the chemicals industry in Spain for the period 2005-2015. Our findings show that firms that collaborate with universities have, in average, more intensive innovation efforts, evidenced in significantly higher costs of R&D labour and capital. Collaborating firms also perform higher sales of incrementally and radically innovative products, generating higher innovation-related profitability in the observed period. The profitability gain of collaborating firms over non-collaborating firms is given mainly by changes in technical efficiency and partly by a technology gap, while it is not supported by changes in firm size/scale and price recovery. Through this paper, we contribute to the understanding of the impact of UFC on firm performance in economic terms.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages37
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2020
Externally publishedYes

Publication series

NameRUNIN Working Paper Series
No.02
Volume2020
ISSN (Electronic)2535-5686

Fingerprint

Financial performance
Innovation
Corporate financial performance
Profitability
Spain
Industry
Business model
Data envelopment analysis
Benchmarking
Efficiency measures
Firm size
Firm performance
Chemical industry
Labor
Technology gap
Innovation process
Index numbers
Technical efficiency
Economics
Costs

Cite this

Manrique, S., & Grifell-Tatjé, E. (2020). Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance. (RUNIN Working Paper Series; Vol. 2020, No. 02). https://doi.org/10.3990/4.2535-5686.2020.02
Manrique, Sergio ; Grifell-Tatjé, Emili. / Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance. 2020. (RUNIN Working Paper Series; 02).
@techreport{ad2197cfee4e484dba76565c94729e64,
title = "Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance",
abstract = "Collaboration between universities and firms has boosted worldwide, due to the transition towards open business models on the industry side and the development of universities’ third mission on the academia side. Such collaboration is expected to contribute positively to the improvement and development of products and practices at firms, which should lead to better corporate financial performance. We argue that these financial benefits should be the major motivation form firms to ‘open’ their R&D activities and interact with universities. Despite there is a broad literature on the determinants of university-firm collaboration (UFC) and its effects on R&D and innovation processes at firms, the study of its impact on corporate financial performance, especially in empirical terms, remains unexplored. This paper attempts to assess the impact of UFC on the corporate financial performance related to firm innovation efforts. To do so, we isolate the innovation-related inputs used by firms to produce radically and incrementally innovative products, and compare the innovation-related profitability of collaborating and non-collaborating firms with a benchmarking model based on Empirical Index Numbers (EINs) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) efficiency measures for a sample of 1,060 observations from the chemicals industry in Spain for the period 2005-2015. Our findings show that firms that collaborate with universities have, in average, more intensive innovation efforts, evidenced in significantly higher costs of R&D labour and capital. Collaborating firms also perform higher sales of incrementally and radically innovative products, generating higher innovation-related profitability in the observed period. The profitability gain of collaborating firms over non-collaborating firms is given mainly by changes in technical efficiency and partly by a technology gap, while it is not supported by changes in firm size/scale and price recovery. Through this paper, we contribute to the understanding of the impact of UFC on firm performance in economic terms.",
author = "Sergio Manrique and Emili Grifell-Tatj{\'e}",
note = "Subseries of the CHEPS working paper series as part of the UT & ECIU RUNIN Ph.D. training network. Paul Benneworth is the series editor This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 722295 The paper is prepared as a chapter for “The urban university and the knowledge economy – new spaces of interaction” edited by Patrizia Ingallina and David Charles, Routledge (forthcoming)",
year = "2020",
doi = "10.3990/4.2535-5686.2020.02",
language = "English",
series = "RUNIN Working Paper Series",
number = "02",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance. / Manrique, Sergio; Grifell-Tatjé, Emili.

2020. (RUNIN Working Paper Series; Vol. 2020, No. 02).

Research output: Working paper

TY - UNPB

T1 - Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance

AU - Manrique, Sergio

AU - Grifell-Tatjé, Emili

N1 - Subseries of the CHEPS working paper series as part of the UT & ECIU RUNIN Ph.D. training network. Paul Benneworth is the series editor This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 722295 The paper is prepared as a chapter for “The urban university and the knowledge economy – new spaces of interaction” edited by Patrizia Ingallina and David Charles, Routledge (forthcoming)

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - Collaboration between universities and firms has boosted worldwide, due to the transition towards open business models on the industry side and the development of universities’ third mission on the academia side. Such collaboration is expected to contribute positively to the improvement and development of products and practices at firms, which should lead to better corporate financial performance. We argue that these financial benefits should be the major motivation form firms to ‘open’ their R&D activities and interact with universities. Despite there is a broad literature on the determinants of university-firm collaboration (UFC) and its effects on R&D and innovation processes at firms, the study of its impact on corporate financial performance, especially in empirical terms, remains unexplored. This paper attempts to assess the impact of UFC on the corporate financial performance related to firm innovation efforts. To do so, we isolate the innovation-related inputs used by firms to produce radically and incrementally innovative products, and compare the innovation-related profitability of collaborating and non-collaborating firms with a benchmarking model based on Empirical Index Numbers (EINs) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) efficiency measures for a sample of 1,060 observations from the chemicals industry in Spain for the period 2005-2015. Our findings show that firms that collaborate with universities have, in average, more intensive innovation efforts, evidenced in significantly higher costs of R&D labour and capital. Collaborating firms also perform higher sales of incrementally and radically innovative products, generating higher innovation-related profitability in the observed period. The profitability gain of collaborating firms over non-collaborating firms is given mainly by changes in technical efficiency and partly by a technology gap, while it is not supported by changes in firm size/scale and price recovery. Through this paper, we contribute to the understanding of the impact of UFC on firm performance in economic terms.

AB - Collaboration between universities and firms has boosted worldwide, due to the transition towards open business models on the industry side and the development of universities’ third mission on the academia side. Such collaboration is expected to contribute positively to the improvement and development of products and practices at firms, which should lead to better corporate financial performance. We argue that these financial benefits should be the major motivation form firms to ‘open’ their R&D activities and interact with universities. Despite there is a broad literature on the determinants of university-firm collaboration (UFC) and its effects on R&D and innovation processes at firms, the study of its impact on corporate financial performance, especially in empirical terms, remains unexplored. This paper attempts to assess the impact of UFC on the corporate financial performance related to firm innovation efforts. To do so, we isolate the innovation-related inputs used by firms to produce radically and incrementally innovative products, and compare the innovation-related profitability of collaborating and non-collaborating firms with a benchmarking model based on Empirical Index Numbers (EINs) and Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) efficiency measures for a sample of 1,060 observations from the chemicals industry in Spain for the period 2005-2015. Our findings show that firms that collaborate with universities have, in average, more intensive innovation efforts, evidenced in significantly higher costs of R&D labour and capital. Collaborating firms also perform higher sales of incrementally and radically innovative products, generating higher innovation-related profitability in the observed period. The profitability gain of collaborating firms over non-collaborating firms is given mainly by changes in technical efficiency and partly by a technology gap, while it is not supported by changes in firm size/scale and price recovery. Through this paper, we contribute to the understanding of the impact of UFC on firm performance in economic terms.

U2 - 10.3990/4.2535-5686.2020.02

DO - 10.3990/4.2535-5686.2020.02

M3 - Working paper

T3 - RUNIN Working Paper Series

BT - Assessing the Impact of University-Firm Collaboration on Innovation-related Financial Performance

ER -