Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system

Gido Hakvoort, B. Reuderink, Michel Obbink

Abstract

Using steady-state visually evoked potential (SSVEP) in brain-computer interface (BCI) systems is the subject of a lot of research. One of the most popular and widely used detection method is using a power spectral density analysis (PSDA). Lately there have been some new methods emerging, one of them is using canonical correlation analysis (CCA) which seems to have some promising improvements and advantages compared to traditional SSVEP detection methods, like better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), lower inter-subject variability and the possibility to use harmonic frequencies, i.e., a serie of frequencies which have the same fundamental frequency. In this research two different SSVEP detection methods, one using PSDA and one using CCA are compared. The results show that the CCA-based detection method performs significantly better than the PSDA-based detection method. The increase of performance can in particular be seen when using harmonic frequencies. While the PSDA-based detection method has difficulties detecting harmonic frequencies, the CCA-based detection method is able to detect harmonic frequencies.
Original languageUndefined
Place of PublicationEnschede
PublisherCentre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT)
Number of pages12
StatePublished - 21 Feb 2011

Publication series

NameCTIT Technical Report Series
PublisherCentre for Telematics and Information Technology, University of Twente
No.TR-CTIT-11-03
ISSN (Print)1381-3625

Fingerprint

Power spectral density
Bioelectric potentials
Brain computer interface
Signal to noise ratio

Keywords

  • steady-state visually evoked potentials
  • EWI-19680
  • EEG
  • Detection
  • Human computer interaction
  • IR-76127
  • Brain-Computer Interfaces
  • METIS-277558

Cite this

Hakvoort, G., Reuderink, B., & Obbink, M. (2011). Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system. (CTIT Technical Report Series; No. TR-CTIT-11-03). Enschede: Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT).

Hakvoort, Gido; Reuderink, B.; Obbink, Michel / Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system.

Enschede : Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT), 2011. 12 p. (CTIT Technical Report Series; No. TR-CTIT-11-03).

Research output: ProfessionalReport

@book{f267d86aef2e4ab39fb34bb68cfb1e27,
title = "Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system",
abstract = "Using steady-state visually evoked potential (SSVEP) in brain-computer interface (BCI) systems is the subject of a lot of research. One of the most popular and widely used detection method is using a power spectral density analysis (PSDA). Lately there have been some new methods emerging, one of them is using canonical correlation analysis (CCA) which seems to have some promising improvements and advantages compared to traditional SSVEP detection methods, like better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), lower inter-subject variability and the possibility to use harmonic frequencies, i.e., a serie of frequencies which have the same fundamental frequency. In this research two different SSVEP detection methods, one using PSDA and one using CCA are compared. The results show that the CCA-based detection method performs significantly better than the PSDA-based detection method. The increase of performance can in particular be seen when using harmonic frequencies. While the PSDA-based detection method has difficulties detecting harmonic frequencies, the CCA-based detection method is able to detect harmonic frequencies.",
keywords = "steady-state visually evoked potentials, EWI-19680, EEG, Detection, Human computer interaction, IR-76127, Brain-Computer Interfaces, METIS-277558",
author = "Gido Hakvoort and B. Reuderink and Michel Obbink",
year = "2011",
month = "2",
series = "CTIT Technical Report Series",
publisher = "Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT)",
number = "TR-CTIT-11-03",
address = "Netherlands",

}

Hakvoort, G, Reuderink, B & Obbink, M 2011, Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system. CTIT Technical Report Series, no. TR-CTIT-11-03, Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT), Enschede.

Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system. / Hakvoort, Gido; Reuderink, B.; Obbink, Michel.

Enschede : Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT), 2011. 12 p. (CTIT Technical Report Series; No. TR-CTIT-11-03).

Research output: ProfessionalReport

TY - BOOK

T1 - Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system

AU - Hakvoort,Gido

AU - Reuderink,B.

AU - Obbink,Michel

PY - 2011/2/21

Y1 - 2011/2/21

N2 - Using steady-state visually evoked potential (SSVEP) in brain-computer interface (BCI) systems is the subject of a lot of research. One of the most popular and widely used detection method is using a power spectral density analysis (PSDA). Lately there have been some new methods emerging, one of them is using canonical correlation analysis (CCA) which seems to have some promising improvements and advantages compared to traditional SSVEP detection methods, like better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), lower inter-subject variability and the possibility to use harmonic frequencies, i.e., a serie of frequencies which have the same fundamental frequency. In this research two different SSVEP detection methods, one using PSDA and one using CCA are compared. The results show that the CCA-based detection method performs significantly better than the PSDA-based detection method. The increase of performance can in particular be seen when using harmonic frequencies. While the PSDA-based detection method has difficulties detecting harmonic frequencies, the CCA-based detection method is able to detect harmonic frequencies.

AB - Using steady-state visually evoked potential (SSVEP) in brain-computer interface (BCI) systems is the subject of a lot of research. One of the most popular and widely used detection method is using a power spectral density analysis (PSDA). Lately there have been some new methods emerging, one of them is using canonical correlation analysis (CCA) which seems to have some promising improvements and advantages compared to traditional SSVEP detection methods, like better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), lower inter-subject variability and the possibility to use harmonic frequencies, i.e., a serie of frequencies which have the same fundamental frequency. In this research two different SSVEP detection methods, one using PSDA and one using CCA are compared. The results show that the CCA-based detection method performs significantly better than the PSDA-based detection method. The increase of performance can in particular be seen when using harmonic frequencies. While the PSDA-based detection method has difficulties detecting harmonic frequencies, the CCA-based detection method is able to detect harmonic frequencies.

KW - steady-state visually evoked potentials

KW - EWI-19680

KW - EEG

KW - Detection

KW - Human computer interaction

KW - IR-76127

KW - Brain-Computer Interfaces

KW - METIS-277558

M3 - Report

T3 - CTIT Technical Report Series

BT - Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system

PB - Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT)

ER -

Hakvoort G, Reuderink B, Obbink M. Comparison of PSDA and CCA detection methods in a SSVEP-based BCI-system. Enschede: Centre for Telematics and Information Technology (CTIT), 2011. 12 p. (CTIT Technical Report Series; TR-CTIT-11-03).