Coping with Intractable Controversies: The Case for Problem Structuring in Policy Design and Analysis

Rob Hoppe, Matthijs Hisschemöller

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterAcademic

393 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This chapter argues that four types of problems can be discerned in the policy process: structured, unstructured, and two types of moderately structured problems. It also argues that policymakers show the inclination to move away from unstructured problems to more structured ones; even at the cost of losing touch with the true complexity and normative volatility of the problems as experienced by other groups. When "containment" efforts fail, problems become unstructured and controversies flare up. This is illustrated in a case study of the so-called "Not In My BackYard"-phenomenon in hazardous waste facility siting. Intractable controversies occur when policymakers stubbornly continue to address the "wrong" policy problem. The chapter shows how these controversies can be transformed into a productive process of learning by problem structuring and problem choice. It discusses political prerequisites for such policy learning and reviews some implications of policy design as well as in policy analysis.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationKnowledge, Power and Participation in Environmental Policy Analysis
EditorsRob Hoppe, Matthijs Hisschemöller, William N. Dunn, Jerry R. Ravetz
Place of PublicationNew Brunswick/London
PublisherTransaction Publishers
Chapter3
Pages47-72
Number of pages26
ISBN (Print)0-7658-0076-4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2001

Publication series

NamePolicy studies review annual
PublisherTransaction Publishers
Volume12

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Coping with Intractable Controversies: The Case for Problem Structuring in Policy Design and Analysis'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Cite this

    Hoppe, R., & Hisschemöller, M. (2001). Coping with Intractable Controversies: The Case for Problem Structuring in Policy Design and Analysis. In R. Hoppe, M. Hisschemöller, W. N. Dunn, & J. R. Ravetz (Eds.), Knowledge, Power and Participation in Environmental Policy Analysis (pp. 47-72). (Policy studies review annual; Vol. 12). New Brunswick/London: Transaction Publishers. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351325721-4