Crime seriousness and participation in restorative justice: The role of time elapsed since the offense

Sven Zebel, Wendy Schreurs, Elze G. Ufkes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)
193 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Restorative justice policies and programs aimed at facilitating victim- offender mediation (VOM) are part of many criminal justice systems around the world. Given its voluntary nature and potential for positive outcomes, the appropriateness and feasibility of VOM after serious offenses is subject to debate in the literature. In light of this discussion, this study first aimed to unravel the prevalence of serious offenses in cases registered for VOM and examined whether crime seriousness predicts whether mediated contact is reached between victims and offenders. Second, it tested the hypothesis that victims of increasingly serious, harmful crimes are more willing to participate when more time has elapsed since the offense in contrast to victims of less serious, harmful crimes. We analyzed 199 cases registered for VOM in the Netherlands and coded the perceived wrongfulness, harmfulness, and average duration of incarceration of an offense as 3 distinct indicators of crime seriousness in these cases. The findings revealed that cases registered for VOM (a) are, in terms of the incarceration duration, on average more serious than all offenses in the population, and (b) resulted in mediated contact (or not) independently of the 3 seriousness indicators. In addition, empirical support was found for the hypothesis that victims' willingness to participate in VOM increased over time after more harmful offenses, whereas it decreased when offenses inflicted less harm. These findings suggest that when VOM programs operate irrespectively of the time elapsed after crime, mediated contact between parties may be as likely after minor and serious offenses.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)385-397
Number of pages13
JournalLaw and human behavior
Volume41
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2017

Fingerprint

Social Justice
Crime
offender-victim mediation
justice
offense
participation
contact
Criminal Law
time
Restorative Justice
Offence
Participation
Netherlands
Offenders
Mediation
offender
Population

Keywords

  • Crime seriousness
  • Participation
  • Restorative justice
  • Time elapsed
  • Victim- offender mediation

Cite this

@article{1df1e691c42145b1b48b94c9972ba276,
title = "Crime seriousness and participation in restorative justice: The role of time elapsed since the offense",
abstract = "Restorative justice policies and programs aimed at facilitating victim- offender mediation (VOM) are part of many criminal justice systems around the world. Given its voluntary nature and potential for positive outcomes, the appropriateness and feasibility of VOM after serious offenses is subject to debate in the literature. In light of this discussion, this study first aimed to unravel the prevalence of serious offenses in cases registered for VOM and examined whether crime seriousness predicts whether mediated contact is reached between victims and offenders. Second, it tested the hypothesis that victims of increasingly serious, harmful crimes are more willing to participate when more time has elapsed since the offense in contrast to victims of less serious, harmful crimes. We analyzed 199 cases registered for VOM in the Netherlands and coded the perceived wrongfulness, harmfulness, and average duration of incarceration of an offense as 3 distinct indicators of crime seriousness in these cases. The findings revealed that cases registered for VOM (a) are, in terms of the incarceration duration, on average more serious than all offenses in the population, and (b) resulted in mediated contact (or not) independently of the 3 seriousness indicators. In addition, empirical support was found for the hypothesis that victims' willingness to participate in VOM increased over time after more harmful offenses, whereas it decreased when offenses inflicted less harm. These findings suggest that when VOM programs operate irrespectively of the time elapsed after crime, mediated contact between parties may be as likely after minor and serious offenses.",
keywords = "Crime seriousness, Participation, Restorative justice, Time elapsed, Victim- offender mediation",
author = "Sven Zebel and Wendy Schreurs and Ufkes, {Elze G.}",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1037/lhb0000242",
language = "English",
volume = "41",
pages = "385--397",
journal = "Law and human behavior",
issn = "0147-7307",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "4",

}

Crime seriousness and participation in restorative justice : The role of time elapsed since the offense. / Zebel, Sven; Schreurs, Wendy; Ufkes, Elze G.

In: Law and human behavior, Vol. 41, No. 4, 01.08.2017, p. 385-397.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Crime seriousness and participation in restorative justice

T2 - The role of time elapsed since the offense

AU - Zebel, Sven

AU - Schreurs, Wendy

AU - Ufkes, Elze G.

PY - 2017/8/1

Y1 - 2017/8/1

N2 - Restorative justice policies and programs aimed at facilitating victim- offender mediation (VOM) are part of many criminal justice systems around the world. Given its voluntary nature and potential for positive outcomes, the appropriateness and feasibility of VOM after serious offenses is subject to debate in the literature. In light of this discussion, this study first aimed to unravel the prevalence of serious offenses in cases registered for VOM and examined whether crime seriousness predicts whether mediated contact is reached between victims and offenders. Second, it tested the hypothesis that victims of increasingly serious, harmful crimes are more willing to participate when more time has elapsed since the offense in contrast to victims of less serious, harmful crimes. We analyzed 199 cases registered for VOM in the Netherlands and coded the perceived wrongfulness, harmfulness, and average duration of incarceration of an offense as 3 distinct indicators of crime seriousness in these cases. The findings revealed that cases registered for VOM (a) are, in terms of the incarceration duration, on average more serious than all offenses in the population, and (b) resulted in mediated contact (or not) independently of the 3 seriousness indicators. In addition, empirical support was found for the hypothesis that victims' willingness to participate in VOM increased over time after more harmful offenses, whereas it decreased when offenses inflicted less harm. These findings suggest that when VOM programs operate irrespectively of the time elapsed after crime, mediated contact between parties may be as likely after minor and serious offenses.

AB - Restorative justice policies and programs aimed at facilitating victim- offender mediation (VOM) are part of many criminal justice systems around the world. Given its voluntary nature and potential for positive outcomes, the appropriateness and feasibility of VOM after serious offenses is subject to debate in the literature. In light of this discussion, this study first aimed to unravel the prevalence of serious offenses in cases registered for VOM and examined whether crime seriousness predicts whether mediated contact is reached between victims and offenders. Second, it tested the hypothesis that victims of increasingly serious, harmful crimes are more willing to participate when more time has elapsed since the offense in contrast to victims of less serious, harmful crimes. We analyzed 199 cases registered for VOM in the Netherlands and coded the perceived wrongfulness, harmfulness, and average duration of incarceration of an offense as 3 distinct indicators of crime seriousness in these cases. The findings revealed that cases registered for VOM (a) are, in terms of the incarceration duration, on average more serious than all offenses in the population, and (b) resulted in mediated contact (or not) independently of the 3 seriousness indicators. In addition, empirical support was found for the hypothesis that victims' willingness to participate in VOM increased over time after more harmful offenses, whereas it decreased when offenses inflicted less harm. These findings suggest that when VOM programs operate irrespectively of the time elapsed after crime, mediated contact between parties may be as likely after minor and serious offenses.

KW - Crime seriousness

KW - Participation

KW - Restorative justice

KW - Time elapsed

KW - Victim- offender mediation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85021753626&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/lhb0000242

DO - 10.1037/lhb0000242

M3 - Article

VL - 41

SP - 385

EP - 397

JO - Law and human behavior

JF - Law and human behavior

SN - 0147-7307

IS - 4

ER -