Critical evaluation of quantification methods for oligonucleotides formulated in lipid nanoparticles

Erik Oude Blenke, Martijn J.W. Evers, Volker Baumann, Johannes Winkler, Gert Storm, Enrico Mastrobattista

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

There is a very large variety in the types of nanoparticulate lipid formulations for oligonucleotides, and remarkably, also a very large heterogeneity in the methods that are used for analyzing oligonucleotide load, encapsulation efficiency and oligonucleotide release. Furthermore, a literature survey showed that the extent to which these procedures are reported in scientific literature varies greatly, with some of them not even reporting any quantification at all. This greatly hampers the reproducibility of nanoparticle preparation between different researchers and between different laboratories, which slows down the clinical translation of such nanomedicines. In this work, a standardized extraction method from liposomes is proposed, in which potential contaminants from the carrier are removed by a simple extraction of the oligonucleotides. These extracts were then analyzed with seven commonly used methods for oligonucleotide quantification, including several absorbance based methods and the most commonly applied dye binding assay. Strikingly, differences in absolute values up to fourfold were found when the same sample was analyzed using different methods which should be taken into consideration when reports using different methods are compared. Furthermore, these results indicate that the most commonly applied method, the dye binding assay, may -without adaptations- not be suitable for short oligonucleotides like siRNAs. The found differences in quantification methods as described here underscore the need for proper documentation of methods to correctly interpret published results, which -with regard to oligonucleotide analysis- is currently lacking in many reports.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)793-802
JournalInternational journal of pharmaceutics
Volume548
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Sep 2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Oligonucleotides
Nanoparticles
Lipids
Coloring Agents
Nanomedicine
Literature
Liposomes
Documentation
Research Personnel

Keywords

  • Dye binding assay
  • Liposomes
  • Nucleic acid
  • Oligonucleotides
  • Quantification
  • UPLC

Cite this

Oude Blenke, Erik ; Evers, Martijn J.W. ; Baumann, Volker ; Winkler, Johannes ; Storm, Gert ; Mastrobattista, Enrico. / Critical evaluation of quantification methods for oligonucleotides formulated in lipid nanoparticles. In: International journal of pharmaceutics. 2018 ; Vol. 548, No. 2. pp. 793-802.
@article{87629554ac2b42bdaf5ccd459544a47b,
title = "Critical evaluation of quantification methods for oligonucleotides formulated in lipid nanoparticles",
abstract = "There is a very large variety in the types of nanoparticulate lipid formulations for oligonucleotides, and remarkably, also a very large heterogeneity in the methods that are used for analyzing oligonucleotide load, encapsulation efficiency and oligonucleotide release. Furthermore, a literature survey showed that the extent to which these procedures are reported in scientific literature varies greatly, with some of them not even reporting any quantification at all. This greatly hampers the reproducibility of nanoparticle preparation between different researchers and between different laboratories, which slows down the clinical translation of such nanomedicines. In this work, a standardized extraction method from liposomes is proposed, in which potential contaminants from the carrier are removed by a simple extraction of the oligonucleotides. These extracts were then analyzed with seven commonly used methods for oligonucleotide quantification, including several absorbance based methods and the most commonly applied dye binding assay. Strikingly, differences in absolute values up to fourfold were found when the same sample was analyzed using different methods which should be taken into consideration when reports using different methods are compared. Furthermore, these results indicate that the most commonly applied method, the dye binding assay, may -without adaptations- not be suitable for short oligonucleotides like siRNAs. The found differences in quantification methods as described here underscore the need for proper documentation of methods to correctly interpret published results, which -with regard to oligonucleotide analysis- is currently lacking in many reports.",
keywords = "Dye binding assay, Liposomes, Nucleic acid, Oligonucleotides, Quantification, UPLC",
author = "{Oude Blenke}, Erik and Evers, {Martijn J.W.} and Volker Baumann and Johannes Winkler and Gert Storm and Enrico Mastrobattista",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.ijpharm.2017.12.035",
language = "English",
volume = "548",
pages = "793--802",
journal = "International journal of pharmaceutics",
issn = "0378-5173",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "2",

}

Critical evaluation of quantification methods for oligonucleotides formulated in lipid nanoparticles. / Oude Blenke, Erik; Evers, Martijn J.W.; Baumann, Volker; Winkler, Johannes; Storm, Gert; Mastrobattista, Enrico.

In: International journal of pharmaceutics, Vol. 548, No. 2, 15.09.2018, p. 793-802.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critical evaluation of quantification methods for oligonucleotides formulated in lipid nanoparticles

AU - Oude Blenke, Erik

AU - Evers, Martijn J.W.

AU - Baumann, Volker

AU - Winkler, Johannes

AU - Storm, Gert

AU - Mastrobattista, Enrico

PY - 2018/9/15

Y1 - 2018/9/15

N2 - There is a very large variety in the types of nanoparticulate lipid formulations for oligonucleotides, and remarkably, also a very large heterogeneity in the methods that are used for analyzing oligonucleotide load, encapsulation efficiency and oligonucleotide release. Furthermore, a literature survey showed that the extent to which these procedures are reported in scientific literature varies greatly, with some of them not even reporting any quantification at all. This greatly hampers the reproducibility of nanoparticle preparation between different researchers and between different laboratories, which slows down the clinical translation of such nanomedicines. In this work, a standardized extraction method from liposomes is proposed, in which potential contaminants from the carrier are removed by a simple extraction of the oligonucleotides. These extracts were then analyzed with seven commonly used methods for oligonucleotide quantification, including several absorbance based methods and the most commonly applied dye binding assay. Strikingly, differences in absolute values up to fourfold were found when the same sample was analyzed using different methods which should be taken into consideration when reports using different methods are compared. Furthermore, these results indicate that the most commonly applied method, the dye binding assay, may -without adaptations- not be suitable for short oligonucleotides like siRNAs. The found differences in quantification methods as described here underscore the need for proper documentation of methods to correctly interpret published results, which -with regard to oligonucleotide analysis- is currently lacking in many reports.

AB - There is a very large variety in the types of nanoparticulate lipid formulations for oligonucleotides, and remarkably, also a very large heterogeneity in the methods that are used for analyzing oligonucleotide load, encapsulation efficiency and oligonucleotide release. Furthermore, a literature survey showed that the extent to which these procedures are reported in scientific literature varies greatly, with some of them not even reporting any quantification at all. This greatly hampers the reproducibility of nanoparticle preparation between different researchers and between different laboratories, which slows down the clinical translation of such nanomedicines. In this work, a standardized extraction method from liposomes is proposed, in which potential contaminants from the carrier are removed by a simple extraction of the oligonucleotides. These extracts were then analyzed with seven commonly used methods for oligonucleotide quantification, including several absorbance based methods and the most commonly applied dye binding assay. Strikingly, differences in absolute values up to fourfold were found when the same sample was analyzed using different methods which should be taken into consideration when reports using different methods are compared. Furthermore, these results indicate that the most commonly applied method, the dye binding assay, may -without adaptations- not be suitable for short oligonucleotides like siRNAs. The found differences in quantification methods as described here underscore the need for proper documentation of methods to correctly interpret published results, which -with regard to oligonucleotide analysis- is currently lacking in many reports.

KW - Dye binding assay

KW - Liposomes

KW - Nucleic acid

KW - Oligonucleotides

KW - Quantification

KW - UPLC

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85039714642&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ijpharm.2017.12.035

DO - 10.1016/j.ijpharm.2017.12.035

M3 - Article

VL - 548

SP - 793

EP - 802

JO - International journal of pharmaceutics

JF - International journal of pharmaceutics

SN - 0378-5173

IS - 2

ER -