Decision-making during a crisis: the interplay of narratives and statistical information before and after crisis communication

Marije H. Bakker (Corresponding Author), José H. Kerstholt, Marco van Bommel, Ellen Giebels

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

79 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Decision-making during a crisis is affected by several sources of information and prior knowledge, such as factual (statistical) information, narratives of others, and real-time governmental messages. The present study investigated how two types of information (statistics and narratives) influence helping behavior after the occurrence of a traffic accident. We used a scripted crisis scenario in a virtual environment, where several types of behavior could be measured. The main dependent variable was whether participants would move the victim or not. By moving the victim, he would be rescued from a potentially unsafe position (the tilted truck could contain poisonous substances), but moving also entailed a risk of increased injury (according to the statistical information the most likely consequence). Our results indicate that more victims were moved in the narrative condition before an official message was received. Participants who had received statistical information or both types of information performed similar to the control condition. After the official message, informing participants to keep distance, more victims were moved in the narrative condition and in the combined narrative and statistical condition. A narrative therefore has stronger effects when (information about) the actual situation matches the narrative’s content. In contrast with our expectations, affective response did not mediate the relationship between narrative information and moving victims. An alternative explanation would be that narratives trigger a more heuristic way of information processing.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-16
Number of pages16
JournalJournal of risk research
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print/First online - 14 May 2018

Fingerprint

crisis communication
Highway accidents
Virtual reality
Trucks
Decision making
Statistics
decision making
narrative
Communication
Crisis communication
traffic accident
information processing
source of information
heuristics
statistics
scenario

Keywords

  • UT-Hybrid-D
  • decision making
  • narratives
  • statistical information
  • virtual environment
  • Crisis communication

Cite this

@article{c2b5876a0fc24f13b6b494e3a86cc246,
title = "Decision-making during a crisis: the interplay of narratives and statistical information before and after crisis communication",
abstract = "Decision-making during a crisis is affected by several sources of information and prior knowledge, such as factual (statistical) information, narratives of others, and real-time governmental messages. The present study investigated how two types of information (statistics and narratives) influence helping behavior after the occurrence of a traffic accident. We used a scripted crisis scenario in a virtual environment, where several types of behavior could be measured. The main dependent variable was whether participants would move the victim or not. By moving the victim, he would be rescued from a potentially unsafe position (the tilted truck could contain poisonous substances), but moving also entailed a risk of increased injury (according to the statistical information the most likely consequence). Our results indicate that more victims were moved in the narrative condition before an official message was received. Participants who had received statistical information or both types of information performed similar to the control condition. After the official message, informing participants to keep distance, more victims were moved in the narrative condition and in the combined narrative and statistical condition. A narrative therefore has stronger effects when (information about) the actual situation matches the narrative’s content. In contrast with our expectations, affective response did not mediate the relationship between narrative information and moving victims. An alternative explanation would be that narratives trigger a more heuristic way of information processing.",
keywords = "UT-Hybrid-D, decision making, narratives, statistical information, virtual environment, Crisis communication",
author = "Bakker, {Marije H.} and Kerstholt, {Jos{\'e} H.} and {van Bommel}, Marco and Ellen Giebels",
note = "Taylor & Francis deal",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "14",
doi = "10.1080/13669877.2018.1473464",
language = "English",
pages = "1--16",
journal = "Journal of risk research",
issn = "1366-9877",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

Decision-making during a crisis : the interplay of narratives and statistical information before and after crisis communication. / Bakker, Marije H. (Corresponding Author); Kerstholt, José H.; van Bommel, Marco; Giebels, Ellen.

In: Journal of risk research, 14.05.2018, p. 1-16.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Decision-making during a crisis

T2 - the interplay of narratives and statistical information before and after crisis communication

AU - Bakker, Marije H.

AU - Kerstholt, José H.

AU - van Bommel, Marco

AU - Giebels, Ellen

N1 - Taylor & Francis deal

PY - 2018/5/14

Y1 - 2018/5/14

N2 - Decision-making during a crisis is affected by several sources of information and prior knowledge, such as factual (statistical) information, narratives of others, and real-time governmental messages. The present study investigated how two types of information (statistics and narratives) influence helping behavior after the occurrence of a traffic accident. We used a scripted crisis scenario in a virtual environment, where several types of behavior could be measured. The main dependent variable was whether participants would move the victim or not. By moving the victim, he would be rescued from a potentially unsafe position (the tilted truck could contain poisonous substances), but moving also entailed a risk of increased injury (according to the statistical information the most likely consequence). Our results indicate that more victims were moved in the narrative condition before an official message was received. Participants who had received statistical information or both types of information performed similar to the control condition. After the official message, informing participants to keep distance, more victims were moved in the narrative condition and in the combined narrative and statistical condition. A narrative therefore has stronger effects when (information about) the actual situation matches the narrative’s content. In contrast with our expectations, affective response did not mediate the relationship between narrative information and moving victims. An alternative explanation would be that narratives trigger a more heuristic way of information processing.

AB - Decision-making during a crisis is affected by several sources of information and prior knowledge, such as factual (statistical) information, narratives of others, and real-time governmental messages. The present study investigated how two types of information (statistics and narratives) influence helping behavior after the occurrence of a traffic accident. We used a scripted crisis scenario in a virtual environment, where several types of behavior could be measured. The main dependent variable was whether participants would move the victim or not. By moving the victim, he would be rescued from a potentially unsafe position (the tilted truck could contain poisonous substances), but moving also entailed a risk of increased injury (according to the statistical information the most likely consequence). Our results indicate that more victims were moved in the narrative condition before an official message was received. Participants who had received statistical information or both types of information performed similar to the control condition. After the official message, informing participants to keep distance, more victims were moved in the narrative condition and in the combined narrative and statistical condition. A narrative therefore has stronger effects when (information about) the actual situation matches the narrative’s content. In contrast with our expectations, affective response did not mediate the relationship between narrative information and moving victims. An alternative explanation would be that narratives trigger a more heuristic way of information processing.

KW - UT-Hybrid-D

KW - decision making

KW - narratives

KW - statistical information

KW - virtual environment

KW - Crisis communication

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85046894156&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/13669877.2018.1473464

DO - 10.1080/13669877.2018.1473464

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 16

JO - Journal of risk research

JF - Journal of risk research

SN - 1366-9877

ER -