Development, implementation and evaluation of a bronchoscopy simulation training program for intensive care Fellows and intensivists in the Netherlands

Simulation-based training can be valuable for teaching bronchoscopy to intensivists, providing a risk-free training environment. We developed, implemented and evaluated a simulation-based flexible bronchoscopy training program for intensive care Fellows and intensivists. This paper presents the development of its design and lessons learned. We used the Analyse, Design, Develop, Implement and Evaluate model for developing and evaluating the training program (Analysis and Design – phase 1, Development – phase 2, Implementation – phase 3, Evaluation – phase 4). In phase 1, two intensivists formulated learning objectives for bronchoscopy in an intensive care setting, which guided the identification and development of training materials and the preliminary training program (phase 2). In phase 3, we tested this program and gathered feedback from participants to guide program modifications. After implementing the adjusted training, we measured participants’ satisfaction using a survey based on closed- and open-ended questions (phase 4). Fifty-seven participants attended the training, with 18 (32%) responding to the questionnaire. Respondents highly appreciated the training program, with median satisfaction scores of 4 or higher on a five-point scale for all closed-ended questions. Respondents appreciated the supervision and feedback and found the simulator equipment relevant for learning bronchoscopy. This description of the program’s development and its evaluation results can serve as a valuable resource for those wishing to establish similar training programs. We recognise that further implementation of evidence-based instructional design principles might enhance the training program’s scientific foundation and effectiveness. We therefore recommend a more evidence-based approach for the design of future bronchoscopy simulation training programs.