Abstract
Background: Participating in a criminal trial may increase the likelihood of developing
psychopathology. In 2021, people bereaved by a plane disaster (flight MH17) had the
opportunity to deliver a victim personal statement (VPS) in Dutch court.
Objective: This longitudinal mixed-method study examined different aspects of 84 bereaved people’s experiences with VPS delivery.
Method: Motivations to deliver, or not deliver, an oral VPS were examined qualitatively using thematic content analysis. Whether background and loss-related variables were related to the decision to deliver a VPS was examined using binary logistic regression analyses. Betweengroup (delivered VPS vs. did not) and within-group (pre- vs. post-VPS) comparisons were made regarding prolonged grief disorder (PGD), posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and depression levels using t-tests and paired t-tests.
Results: Bereaved people were most frequently motivated to deliver an oral VPS to describe the impact of the incident, while those who did not deliver an oral VPS commonly wanted to protect themselves from the perceived emotional burden. None of the correlates – i.e. biological sex, age, level of education, number of losses, and (closest) relationship to the deceased – were related to the decision to deliver a VPS. Lastly, significantly higher PGD, PTSD, and depression levels were reported by people who delivered a VPS than those who did not, before and after the court hearing. No significant within-group differences were found over time.
Conclusions: Professionals may provide emotional support to bereaved people who want to deliver a VPS and manage their expectations if they want to deliver a VPS for the purpose of symptom reduction. Future research may benefit from examining other ways in which VPS delivery might have beneficial or detrimental effects for specific individuals. Overall, implementing VPS delivery in court on the basis of emotional restoration remains empirically unsupported, if defined as a reduction in psychopathological levels.
psychopathology. In 2021, people bereaved by a plane disaster (flight MH17) had the
opportunity to deliver a victim personal statement (VPS) in Dutch court.
Objective: This longitudinal mixed-method study examined different aspects of 84 bereaved people’s experiences with VPS delivery.
Method: Motivations to deliver, or not deliver, an oral VPS were examined qualitatively using thematic content analysis. Whether background and loss-related variables were related to the decision to deliver a VPS was examined using binary logistic regression analyses. Betweengroup (delivered VPS vs. did not) and within-group (pre- vs. post-VPS) comparisons were made regarding prolonged grief disorder (PGD), posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and depression levels using t-tests and paired t-tests.
Results: Bereaved people were most frequently motivated to deliver an oral VPS to describe the impact of the incident, while those who did not deliver an oral VPS commonly wanted to protect themselves from the perceived emotional burden. None of the correlates – i.e. biological sex, age, level of education, number of losses, and (closest) relationship to the deceased – were related to the decision to deliver a VPS. Lastly, significantly higher PGD, PTSD, and depression levels were reported by people who delivered a VPS than those who did not, before and after the court hearing. No significant within-group differences were found over time.
Conclusions: Professionals may provide emotional support to bereaved people who want to deliver a VPS and manage their expectations if they want to deliver a VPS for the purpose of symptom reduction. Future research may benefit from examining other ways in which VPS delivery might have beneficial or detrimental effects for specific individuals. Overall, implementing VPS delivery in court on the basis of emotional restoration remains empirically unsupported, if defined as a reduction in psychopathological levels.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Article number | 2297541 |
| Pages (from-to) | 1-14 |
| Number of pages | 14 |
| Journal | European Journal of psychotraumatology |
| Volume | 15 |
| Issue number | 1 |
| Early online date | 29 Jan 2024 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - 2024 |
Keywords
- Prolonged grief
- Posttraumatic stress
- Depression
- Victim impact statement
- Bereavement
- Trauma
- Homicide
- Motivation
