Hegel, the Struggle for Recognition, and Robots

Nolen Gertz (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

84 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

While the mediational theories of Don Ihde and Peter-Paul Verbeek have helped to uncover the role that technologies play in ethical life, the role that technologies play in political life has received far less attention. In order to fill in this gap, I turn to the mediational theory of Hegel, as Hegel shows how the mediated nature of experience is vital to understanding the development of both ethical and political life. Through examples found in the military, in particular concerning the relationship between explosive ordnance detonation (EOD) soldiers and robots, I illustrate how Hegel’s analysis of the “struggle for recognition” can be used to understand human-technology relations from a political perspective. This political perspective can consequently help us to appreciate how technologies come to have a role in political life through our ability to experience solidarity with technology, a solidarity that is experienced by users due to the recognition of technologies as serving roles in society that I describe as functionally equivalent to the social roles of the user. The realization of this functional equivalence allows users to learn how they are perceived and respected by society through the experience of how functionally equivalent technologies are perceived and respected. Consequently, I conclude by focusing on the Dallas Police Department having turned an EOD robot from a life-saving to a life-taking device in order to show why Hegel is necessary for helping us to understand the political significance of recognizing and of misrecognizing technologies.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)138-157
JournalTechné: Research in Philosophy and Technology
Volume22
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Robot
Georg W.F. Hegel
Political Life
Solidarity
Police
Military
Equivalence
Soldiers
Dallas

Keywords

  • Mediation theory
  • Ethics of technology
  • Politics of technology
  • Robotics
  • Hegel

Cite this

@article{7394aae611454e7590e4410cae671dba,
title = "Hegel, the Struggle for Recognition, and Robots",
abstract = "While the mediational theories of Don Ihde and Peter-Paul Verbeek have helped to uncover the role that technologies play in ethical life, the role that technologies play in political life has received far less attention. In order to fill in this gap, I turn to the mediational theory of Hegel, as Hegel shows how the mediated nature of experience is vital to understanding the development of both ethical and political life. Through examples found in the military, in particular concerning the relationship between explosive ordnance detonation (EOD) soldiers and robots, I illustrate how Hegel’s analysis of the “struggle for recognition” can be used to understand human-technology relations from a political perspective. This political perspective can consequently help us to appreciate how technologies come to have a role in political life through our ability to experience solidarity with technology, a solidarity that is experienced by users due to the recognition of technologies as serving roles in society that I describe as functionally equivalent to the social roles of the user. The realization of this functional equivalence allows users to learn how they are perceived and respected by society through the experience of how functionally equivalent technologies are perceived and respected. Consequently, I conclude by focusing on the Dallas Police Department having turned an EOD robot from a life-saving to a life-taking device in order to show why Hegel is necessary for helping us to understand the political significance of recognizing and of misrecognizing technologies.",
keywords = "Mediation theory, Ethics of technology, Politics of technology, Robotics, Hegel",
author = "Nolen Gertz",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.5840/techne201832080",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "138--157",
journal = "Techn{\'e}: Research in Philosophy and Technology",
issn = "1091-8264",
publisher = "Society for Philosophy and Technology",
number = "2",

}

Hegel, the Struggle for Recognition, and Robots. / Gertz, Nolen (Corresponding Author).

In: Techné: Research in Philosophy and Technology, Vol. 22, No. 2, 2018, p. 138-157.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Hegel, the Struggle for Recognition, and Robots

AU - Gertz, Nolen

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - While the mediational theories of Don Ihde and Peter-Paul Verbeek have helped to uncover the role that technologies play in ethical life, the role that technologies play in political life has received far less attention. In order to fill in this gap, I turn to the mediational theory of Hegel, as Hegel shows how the mediated nature of experience is vital to understanding the development of both ethical and political life. Through examples found in the military, in particular concerning the relationship between explosive ordnance detonation (EOD) soldiers and robots, I illustrate how Hegel’s analysis of the “struggle for recognition” can be used to understand human-technology relations from a political perspective. This political perspective can consequently help us to appreciate how technologies come to have a role in political life through our ability to experience solidarity with technology, a solidarity that is experienced by users due to the recognition of technologies as serving roles in society that I describe as functionally equivalent to the social roles of the user. The realization of this functional equivalence allows users to learn how they are perceived and respected by society through the experience of how functionally equivalent technologies are perceived and respected. Consequently, I conclude by focusing on the Dallas Police Department having turned an EOD robot from a life-saving to a life-taking device in order to show why Hegel is necessary for helping us to understand the political significance of recognizing and of misrecognizing technologies.

AB - While the mediational theories of Don Ihde and Peter-Paul Verbeek have helped to uncover the role that technologies play in ethical life, the role that technologies play in political life has received far less attention. In order to fill in this gap, I turn to the mediational theory of Hegel, as Hegel shows how the mediated nature of experience is vital to understanding the development of both ethical and political life. Through examples found in the military, in particular concerning the relationship between explosive ordnance detonation (EOD) soldiers and robots, I illustrate how Hegel’s analysis of the “struggle for recognition” can be used to understand human-technology relations from a political perspective. This political perspective can consequently help us to appreciate how technologies come to have a role in political life through our ability to experience solidarity with technology, a solidarity that is experienced by users due to the recognition of technologies as serving roles in society that I describe as functionally equivalent to the social roles of the user. The realization of this functional equivalence allows users to learn how they are perceived and respected by society through the experience of how functionally equivalent technologies are perceived and respected. Consequently, I conclude by focusing on the Dallas Police Department having turned an EOD robot from a life-saving to a life-taking device in order to show why Hegel is necessary for helping us to understand the political significance of recognizing and of misrecognizing technologies.

KW - Mediation theory

KW - Ethics of technology

KW - Politics of technology

KW - Robotics

KW - Hegel

U2 - 10.5840/techne201832080

DO - 10.5840/techne201832080

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 138

EP - 157

JO - Techné: Research in Philosophy and Technology

JF - Techné: Research in Philosophy and Technology

SN - 1091-8264

IS - 2

ER -