Incertitudes in design decisions: Impediments or instruments?

J. de Lange, E.J. Oude Luttikhuis, E. Lutters

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademicpeer-review

    7 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    In product development, reasoning based on information content progressively complements sheer process driven approaches. Here, the coherent set of design decisions is seen as the backbone that enables the design team to initiate, substantiate and assess the evolvement of development trajectories against the context and the requirement specification. Habitually, design decisions are seen as means to reduce uncertainty in development cycles, while implicitly disavowing or ignoring the elusivenesses of the decisions themselves. A different approach is taken here, by making the role of uncertainty, ambiguity, volatility and indeterminism in decision making explicit, both as concerns the underlying information and the process itself. For now, this does not yet overthrow the way in which products are developed, but it does substantiate an understanding of decision accuracy, reliability and sensitivity. With this, product developers are challenged to explicitly address design decisions by purposefully employing knowledge on the incertitudes inherent to product development.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationInternational Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016
    Subtitle of host publicationProceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness
    EditorsDimitri Dimitrov, Gert Adriaan Oosthuizen
    Place of PublicationStellenbosch
    PublisherStellenbosch University
    Pages101-107
    Number of pages7
    ISBN (Print)978-0-7972-1602-0
    Publication statusPublished - 27 Jan 2016
    EventInternational Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness - Stellenbosch, South Africa
    Duration: 27 Jan 201629 Jan 2016

    Conference

    ConferenceInternational Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016
    Abbreviated titleCOMA
    CountrySouth Africa
    CityStellenbosch
    Period27/01/1629/01/16

    Fingerprint

    Impediments
    Product development
    Uncertainty
    Trajectory
    Developer
    Requirements specification
    Decision making
    Information content

    Keywords

    • Design method
    • uncertainty
    • decision making

    Cite this

    de Lange, J., Oude Luttikhuis, E. J., & Lutters, E. (2016). Incertitudes in design decisions: Impediments or instruments? In D. Dimitrov, & G. A. Oosthuizen (Eds.), International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Proceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness (pp. 101-107). Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University.
    de Lange, J. ; Oude Luttikhuis, E.J. ; Lutters, E. / Incertitudes in design decisions : Impediments or instruments?. International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Proceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness. editor / Dimitri Dimitrov ; Gert Adriaan Oosthuizen. Stellenbosch : Stellenbosch University, 2016. pp. 101-107
    @inproceedings{5389ba095e154616a77c9274bee99fe4,
    title = "Incertitudes in design decisions: Impediments or instruments?",
    abstract = "In product development, reasoning based on information content progressively complements sheer process driven approaches. Here, the coherent set of design decisions is seen as the backbone that enables the design team to initiate, substantiate and assess the evolvement of development trajectories against the context and the requirement specification. Habitually, design decisions are seen as means to reduce uncertainty in development cycles, while implicitly disavowing or ignoring the elusivenesses of the decisions themselves. A different approach is taken here, by making the role of uncertainty, ambiguity, volatility and indeterminism in decision making explicit, both as concerns the underlying information and the process itself. For now, this does not yet overthrow the way in which products are developed, but it does substantiate an understanding of decision accuracy, reliability and sensitivity. With this, product developers are challenged to explicitly address design decisions by purposefully employing knowledge on the incertitudes inherent to product development.",
    keywords = "Design method, uncertainty, decision making",
    author = "{de Lange}, J. and {Oude Luttikhuis}, E.J. and E. Lutters",
    year = "2016",
    month = "1",
    day = "27",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "978-0-7972-1602-0",
    pages = "101--107",
    editor = "Dimitri Dimitrov and Oosthuizen, {Gert Adriaan}",
    booktitle = "International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016",
    publisher = "Stellenbosch University",

    }

    de Lange, J, Oude Luttikhuis, EJ & Lutters, E 2016, Incertitudes in design decisions: Impediments or instruments? in D Dimitrov & GA Oosthuizen (eds), International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Proceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness. Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, pp. 101-107, International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 27/01/16.

    Incertitudes in design decisions : Impediments or instruments? / de Lange, J.; Oude Luttikhuis, E.J.; Lutters, E.

    International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Proceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness. ed. / Dimitri Dimitrov; Gert Adriaan Oosthuizen. Stellenbosch : Stellenbosch University, 2016. p. 101-107.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionAcademicpeer-review

    TY - GEN

    T1 - Incertitudes in design decisions

    T2 - Impediments or instruments?

    AU - de Lange, J.

    AU - Oude Luttikhuis, E.J.

    AU - Lutters, E.

    PY - 2016/1/27

    Y1 - 2016/1/27

    N2 - In product development, reasoning based on information content progressively complements sheer process driven approaches. Here, the coherent set of design decisions is seen as the backbone that enables the design team to initiate, substantiate and assess the evolvement of development trajectories against the context and the requirement specification. Habitually, design decisions are seen as means to reduce uncertainty in development cycles, while implicitly disavowing or ignoring the elusivenesses of the decisions themselves. A different approach is taken here, by making the role of uncertainty, ambiguity, volatility and indeterminism in decision making explicit, both as concerns the underlying information and the process itself. For now, this does not yet overthrow the way in which products are developed, but it does substantiate an understanding of decision accuracy, reliability and sensitivity. With this, product developers are challenged to explicitly address design decisions by purposefully employing knowledge on the incertitudes inherent to product development.

    AB - In product development, reasoning based on information content progressively complements sheer process driven approaches. Here, the coherent set of design decisions is seen as the backbone that enables the design team to initiate, substantiate and assess the evolvement of development trajectories against the context and the requirement specification. Habitually, design decisions are seen as means to reduce uncertainty in development cycles, while implicitly disavowing or ignoring the elusivenesses of the decisions themselves. A different approach is taken here, by making the role of uncertainty, ambiguity, volatility and indeterminism in decision making explicit, both as concerns the underlying information and the process itself. For now, this does not yet overthrow the way in which products are developed, but it does substantiate an understanding of decision accuracy, reliability and sensitivity. With this, product developers are challenged to explicitly address design decisions by purposefully employing knowledge on the incertitudes inherent to product development.

    KW - Design method

    KW - uncertainty

    KW - decision making

    M3 - Conference contribution

    SN - 978-0-7972-1602-0

    SP - 101

    EP - 107

    BT - International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016

    A2 - Dimitrov, Dimitri

    A2 - Oosthuizen, Gert Adriaan

    PB - Stellenbosch University

    CY - Stellenbosch

    ER -

    de Lange J, Oude Luttikhuis EJ, Lutters E. Incertitudes in design decisions: Impediments or instruments? In Dimitrov D, Oosthuizen GA, editors, International Conference on Competitive Manufacturing, COMA 2016: Proceedings: Resource Efficiency for Global Competitiveness. Stellenbosch: Stellenbosch University. 2016. p. 101-107