Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds

Xiaohong Huang, Ronald Mahieu

    Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

    56 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    This paper studies the investment performance of pension funds with a focus on their ability in implementing the investment strategy. We use a sample of Dutch industry-wide pension funds, which are obliged by law to report their investment performance according to the so-called z-score. The z-score is a benchmark- and risk-adjusted performance measure where the benchmarks are chosen a priori preventing manipulation in the score calcualtion. We find that pension funds as a group cannot beat their self-selected benchmarks and show no performance persistence. It reflects that pension funds on average do not add value in implementing their investment strategy. Cross-sectionally, it turns out that large funds are better able to beat their benchmarks persistently than small funds
    Original languageEnglish
    Place of PublicationTilburg
    PublisherNETSPAR
    Number of pages27
    Publication statusPublished - 2010

    Publication series

    NameNetspar discussion papers
    No.09/2010-038

    Fingerprint

    Benchmark
    Performance persistence
    Pension funds
    Investment performance
    Z-score
    Investment strategy
    Industry
    Manipulation
    Risk-adjusted performance
    Performance measures

    Keywords

    • IR-73449

    Cite this

    Huang, X., & Mahieu, R. (2010). Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds. (Netspar discussion papers; No. 09/2010-038). Tilburg: NETSPAR.
    Huang, Xiaohong ; Mahieu, Ronald. / Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds. Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2010. (Netspar discussion papers; 09/2010-038).
    @techreport{f2a04483bf454a1ca7cba56b07abdcf8,
    title = "Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds",
    abstract = "This paper studies the investment performance of pension funds with a focus on their ability in implementing the investment strategy. We use a sample of Dutch industry-wide pension funds, which are obliged by law to report their investment performance according to the so-called z-score. The z-score is a benchmark- and risk-adjusted performance measure where the benchmarks are chosen a priori preventing manipulation in the score calcualtion. We find that pension funds as a group cannot beat their self-selected benchmarks and show no performance persistence. It reflects that pension funds on average do not add value in implementing their investment strategy. Cross-sectionally, it turns out that large funds are better able to beat their benchmarks persistently than small funds",
    keywords = "IR-73449",
    author = "Xiaohong Huang and Ronald Mahieu",
    year = "2010",
    language = "English",
    series = "Netspar discussion papers",
    publisher = "NETSPAR",
    number = "09/2010-038",
    type = "WorkingPaper",
    institution = "NETSPAR",

    }

    Huang, X & Mahieu, R 2010 'Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds' Netspar discussion papers, no. 09/2010-038, NETSPAR, Tilburg.

    Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds. / Huang, Xiaohong; Mahieu, Ronald.

    Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2010. (Netspar discussion papers; No. 09/2010-038).

    Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

    TY - UNPB

    T1 - Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds

    AU - Huang, Xiaohong

    AU - Mahieu, Ronald

    PY - 2010

    Y1 - 2010

    N2 - This paper studies the investment performance of pension funds with a focus on their ability in implementing the investment strategy. We use a sample of Dutch industry-wide pension funds, which are obliged by law to report their investment performance according to the so-called z-score. The z-score is a benchmark- and risk-adjusted performance measure where the benchmarks are chosen a priori preventing manipulation in the score calcualtion. We find that pension funds as a group cannot beat their self-selected benchmarks and show no performance persistence. It reflects that pension funds on average do not add value in implementing their investment strategy. Cross-sectionally, it turns out that large funds are better able to beat their benchmarks persistently than small funds

    AB - This paper studies the investment performance of pension funds with a focus on their ability in implementing the investment strategy. We use a sample of Dutch industry-wide pension funds, which are obliged by law to report their investment performance according to the so-called z-score. The z-score is a benchmark- and risk-adjusted performance measure where the benchmarks are chosen a priori preventing manipulation in the score calcualtion. We find that pension funds as a group cannot beat their self-selected benchmarks and show no performance persistence. It reflects that pension funds on average do not add value in implementing their investment strategy. Cross-sectionally, it turns out that large funds are better able to beat their benchmarks persistently than small funds

    KW - IR-73449

    M3 - Discussion paper

    T3 - Netspar discussion papers

    BT - Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds

    PB - NETSPAR

    CY - Tilburg

    ER -

    Huang X, Mahieu R. Performance Persistence of Dutch Pension Funds. Tilburg: NETSPAR. 2010. (Netspar discussion papers; 09/2010-038).