Qualitative Effects of Knowledge Rules in Probabilistic Data Integration

Maurice van Keulen, Ander de Keijzer

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

40 Downloads (Pure)


One of the problems in data integration is data overlap: the fact that different data sources have data on the same real world entities. Much development time in data integration projects is devoted to entity resolution. Often advanced similarity measurement techniques are used to remove semantic duplicates from the integration result or solve other semantic conflicts, but it proofs impossible to get rid of all semantic problems in data integration. An often-used rule of thumb states that about 90% of the development effort is devoted to solving the remaining 10% hard cases. In an attempt to significantly decrease human effort at data integration time, we have proposed an approach that stores any remaining semantic uncertainty and conflicts in a probabilistic database enabling it to already be meaningfully used. The main development effort in our approach is devoted to defining and tuning knowledge rules and thresholds. Rules and thresholds directly impact the size and quality of the integration result. We measure integration quality indirectly by measuring the quality of answers to queries on the integrated data set in an information retrieval-like way. The main contribution of this report is an experimental investigation of the effects and sensitivity of rule definition and threshold tuning on the integration quality. This proves that our approach indeed reduces development effort — and not merely shifts the effort to rule definition and threshold tuning — by showing that setting rough safe thresholds and defining only a few rules suffices to produce a ‘good enough’ integration that can be meaningfully used.
Original languageUndefined
Place of PublicationEnschede
PublisherDatabases (DB)
Number of pages14
Publication statusPublished - 26 Jun 2008

Publication series

NameCTIT Technical Report Series
PublisherCentre for Telematics and Information Technology, University of Twente
ISSN (Print)1381-3625


  • IR-64897
  • EWI-13123
  • METIS-251105

Cite this

van Keulen, M., & de Keijzer, A. (2008). Qualitative Effects of Knowledge Rules in Probabilistic Data Integration. (CTIT Technical Report Series; No. DTR08-9/TR-CTIT-08-42). Enschede: Databases (DB).