Scaffolding learning by modelling: The effects of partially worked-out models

Y.G. Mulder, Lars Bollen, Ton de Jong, Adrianus W. Lazonder

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

16 Citations (Scopus)
157 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Creating executable computer models is a potentially powerful approach to science learning. Learning by modelling is also challenging because students can easily get overwhelmed by the inherent complexities of the task. This study investigated whether offering partially worked-out models can facilitate students’ modelling practices and promote learning. Partially worked-out models were expected to aid model construction by revealing the overall structure of the model, and thus enabling student to create better models and learn from the experience. This assumption was tested in high school biology classes where students modelled the human glucose-insulin regulatory system. Students either received support in the form of a partial model that outlined the basic structure of the glucose-insulin system (PM condition; n = 26), an extended partial model that also contained a set of variables students could use to complete the model (PM+ condition; n = 21), or no support (control condition; n = 23). Results showed a significant knowledge increase from pretest to posttest in all conditions. Consistent with expectations, knowledge gains were higher in the two partial model conditions than in the control condition. Students in both partial model conditions also ran their model more often to check its accuracy, and eventually built better models than students from the control condition. Comparison between the PM and PM+ conditions showed that more extensive support further increased knowledge acquisition, model quality, and model testing activities. Based on these findings, it was concluded that partial solutions can support learning by modelling, and that offering both a structure of a model and a list of variables yields the best results
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)502-523
JournalJournal of research in science teaching
Volume53
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 9 Jun 2016

Fingerprint

learning
student
knowledge acquisition
biology
science
school
experience

Keywords

  • IR-98355
  • METIS-313497

Cite this

Mulder, Y.G. ; Bollen, Lars ; de Jong, Ton ; Lazonder, Adrianus W. / Scaffolding learning by modelling: The effects of partially worked-out models. In: Journal of research in science teaching. 2016 ; Vol. 53, No. 3. pp. 502-523.
@article{bad62042e02342bcb2c3f5fe5c510997,
title = "Scaffolding learning by modelling: The effects of partially worked-out models",
abstract = "Creating executable computer models is a potentially powerful approach to science learning. Learning by modelling is also challenging because students can easily get overwhelmed by the inherent complexities of the task. This study investigated whether offering partially worked-out models can facilitate students’ modelling practices and promote learning. Partially worked-out models were expected to aid model construction by revealing the overall structure of the model, and thus enabling student to create better models and learn from the experience. This assumption was tested in high school biology classes where students modelled the human glucose-insulin regulatory system. Students either received support in the form of a partial model that outlined the basic structure of the glucose-insulin system (PM condition; n = 26), an extended partial model that also contained a set of variables students could use to complete the model (PM+ condition; n = 21), or no support (control condition; n = 23). Results showed a significant knowledge increase from pretest to posttest in all conditions. Consistent with expectations, knowledge gains were higher in the two partial model conditions than in the control condition. Students in both partial model conditions also ran their model more often to check its accuracy, and eventually built better models than students from the control condition. Comparison between the PM and PM+ conditions showed that more extensive support further increased knowledge acquisition, model quality, and model testing activities. Based on these findings, it was concluded that partial solutions can support learning by modelling, and that offering both a structure of a model and a list of variables yields the best results",
keywords = "IR-98355, METIS-313497",
author = "Y.G. Mulder and Lars Bollen and {de Jong}, Ton and Lazonder, {Adrianus W.}",
year = "2016",
month = "6",
day = "9",
doi = "10.1002/tea.21260",
language = "English",
volume = "53",
pages = "502--523",
journal = "Journal of research in science teaching",
issn = "0022-4308",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "3",

}

Scaffolding learning by modelling: The effects of partially worked-out models. / Mulder, Y.G.; Bollen, Lars; de Jong, Ton; Lazonder, Adrianus W.

In: Journal of research in science teaching, Vol. 53, No. 3, 09.06.2016, p. 502-523.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Scaffolding learning by modelling: The effects of partially worked-out models

AU - Mulder, Y.G.

AU - Bollen, Lars

AU - de Jong, Ton

AU - Lazonder, Adrianus W.

PY - 2016/6/9

Y1 - 2016/6/9

N2 - Creating executable computer models is a potentially powerful approach to science learning. Learning by modelling is also challenging because students can easily get overwhelmed by the inherent complexities of the task. This study investigated whether offering partially worked-out models can facilitate students’ modelling practices and promote learning. Partially worked-out models were expected to aid model construction by revealing the overall structure of the model, and thus enabling student to create better models and learn from the experience. This assumption was tested in high school biology classes where students modelled the human glucose-insulin regulatory system. Students either received support in the form of a partial model that outlined the basic structure of the glucose-insulin system (PM condition; n = 26), an extended partial model that also contained a set of variables students could use to complete the model (PM+ condition; n = 21), or no support (control condition; n = 23). Results showed a significant knowledge increase from pretest to posttest in all conditions. Consistent with expectations, knowledge gains were higher in the two partial model conditions than in the control condition. Students in both partial model conditions also ran their model more often to check its accuracy, and eventually built better models than students from the control condition. Comparison between the PM and PM+ conditions showed that more extensive support further increased knowledge acquisition, model quality, and model testing activities. Based on these findings, it was concluded that partial solutions can support learning by modelling, and that offering both a structure of a model and a list of variables yields the best results

AB - Creating executable computer models is a potentially powerful approach to science learning. Learning by modelling is also challenging because students can easily get overwhelmed by the inherent complexities of the task. This study investigated whether offering partially worked-out models can facilitate students’ modelling practices and promote learning. Partially worked-out models were expected to aid model construction by revealing the overall structure of the model, and thus enabling student to create better models and learn from the experience. This assumption was tested in high school biology classes where students modelled the human glucose-insulin regulatory system. Students either received support in the form of a partial model that outlined the basic structure of the glucose-insulin system (PM condition; n = 26), an extended partial model that also contained a set of variables students could use to complete the model (PM+ condition; n = 21), or no support (control condition; n = 23). Results showed a significant knowledge increase from pretest to posttest in all conditions. Consistent with expectations, knowledge gains were higher in the two partial model conditions than in the control condition. Students in both partial model conditions also ran their model more often to check its accuracy, and eventually built better models than students from the control condition. Comparison between the PM and PM+ conditions showed that more extensive support further increased knowledge acquisition, model quality, and model testing activities. Based on these findings, it was concluded that partial solutions can support learning by modelling, and that offering both a structure of a model and a list of variables yields the best results

KW - IR-98355

KW - METIS-313497

U2 - 10.1002/tea.21260

DO - 10.1002/tea.21260

M3 - Article

VL - 53

SP - 502

EP - 523

JO - Journal of research in science teaching

JF - Journal of research in science teaching

SN - 0022-4308

IS - 3

ER -