Sensemaking in Military Critical Incidents: The Impact of Moral Intensity

Miriam de Graaff (Corresponding Author), Ellen Giebels, Dominique J.W. Meijer, Desiree E.M. Verweij

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)
22 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This study explores the relationship between moral intensity and the use of different sensemaking strategies in military critical incidents. First, narratives of military personnel were used to select prototypical high/low moral intensity critical incidents. In a follow-up, a scenario study was conducted with active duty military personnel (N = 325) to examine the relationship between moral intensity (high vs. low) and the use of sensemaking tactics. This study offers three main conclusions. First, the use of sensemaking tactics is strongly tied to the level of moral intensity in the situation. In high-intense situations, the servicemen draw on previous experiences, prediction of consequences, and help of others to recognize and interpret the situation. Less attention goes out to higher level critical thinking (i.e., moral awareness, integrating available information, and analyzing personal biases in the decision-making process). Thus, it seems that in these critical incidents, the servicemen react without giving room for thorough consideration and deliberation. Second, the number of deployments a serviceman experienced influences the perceived seriousness and harmfulness of the situation negatively in low-intense situations. Finally, and in line with earlier studies, the results indicate that the concept of moral intensity is formed out of three rather than the six dimensions originally proposed by Jones (1991). The implications of these findings are discussed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)749-778
JournalBusiness & society
Volume58
Issue number4
Early online date30 Nov 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

incident
Military
tactics
personnel
available information
deliberation
decision-making process
Sensemaking
Critical incidents
Moral intensity
scenario
narrative
trend
experience
Tactics
Personnel

Keywords

  • UT-Hybrid-D

Cite this

de Graaff, Miriam ; Giebels, Ellen ; Meijer, Dominique J.W. ; Verweij, Desiree E.M. / Sensemaking in Military Critical Incidents: The Impact of Moral Intensity. In: Business & society. 2019 ; Vol. 58, No. 4. pp. 749-778.
@article{2fe74f8878b741afb28d2f8e58468323,
title = "Sensemaking in Military Critical Incidents: The Impact of Moral Intensity",
abstract = "This study explores the relationship between moral intensity and the use of different sensemaking strategies in military critical incidents. First, narratives of military personnel were used to select prototypical high/low moral intensity critical incidents. In a follow-up, a scenario study was conducted with active duty military personnel (N = 325) to examine the relationship between moral intensity (high vs. low) and the use of sensemaking tactics. This study offers three main conclusions. First, the use of sensemaking tactics is strongly tied to the level of moral intensity in the situation. In high-intense situations, the servicemen draw on previous experiences, prediction of consequences, and help of others to recognize and interpret the situation. Less attention goes out to higher level critical thinking (i.e., moral awareness, integrating available information, and analyzing personal biases in the decision-making process). Thus, it seems that in these critical incidents, the servicemen react without giving room for thorough consideration and deliberation. Second, the number of deployments a serviceman experienced influences the perceived seriousness and harmfulness of the situation negatively in low-intense situations. Finally, and in line with earlier studies, the results indicate that the concept of moral intensity is formed out of three rather than the six dimensions originally proposed by Jones (1991). The implications of these findings are discussed.",
keywords = "UT-Hybrid-D",
author = "{de Graaff}, Miriam and Ellen Giebels and Meijer, {Dominique J.W.} and Verweij, {Desiree E.M.}",
note = "Sage deal",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0007650316680996",
language = "English",
volume = "58",
pages = "749--778",
journal = "Business & society",
issn = "0007-6503",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "4",

}

Sensemaking in Military Critical Incidents: The Impact of Moral Intensity. / de Graaff, Miriam (Corresponding Author); Giebels, Ellen; Meijer, Dominique J.W.; Verweij, Desiree E.M.

In: Business & society, Vol. 58, No. 4, 01.04.2019, p. 749-778.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sensemaking in Military Critical Incidents: The Impact of Moral Intensity

AU - de Graaff, Miriam

AU - Giebels, Ellen

AU - Meijer, Dominique J.W.

AU - Verweij, Desiree E.M.

N1 - Sage deal

PY - 2019/4/1

Y1 - 2019/4/1

N2 - This study explores the relationship between moral intensity and the use of different sensemaking strategies in military critical incidents. First, narratives of military personnel were used to select prototypical high/low moral intensity critical incidents. In a follow-up, a scenario study was conducted with active duty military personnel (N = 325) to examine the relationship between moral intensity (high vs. low) and the use of sensemaking tactics. This study offers three main conclusions. First, the use of sensemaking tactics is strongly tied to the level of moral intensity in the situation. In high-intense situations, the servicemen draw on previous experiences, prediction of consequences, and help of others to recognize and interpret the situation. Less attention goes out to higher level critical thinking (i.e., moral awareness, integrating available information, and analyzing personal biases in the decision-making process). Thus, it seems that in these critical incidents, the servicemen react without giving room for thorough consideration and deliberation. Second, the number of deployments a serviceman experienced influences the perceived seriousness and harmfulness of the situation negatively in low-intense situations. Finally, and in line with earlier studies, the results indicate that the concept of moral intensity is formed out of three rather than the six dimensions originally proposed by Jones (1991). The implications of these findings are discussed.

AB - This study explores the relationship between moral intensity and the use of different sensemaking strategies in military critical incidents. First, narratives of military personnel were used to select prototypical high/low moral intensity critical incidents. In a follow-up, a scenario study was conducted with active duty military personnel (N = 325) to examine the relationship between moral intensity (high vs. low) and the use of sensemaking tactics. This study offers three main conclusions. First, the use of sensemaking tactics is strongly tied to the level of moral intensity in the situation. In high-intense situations, the servicemen draw on previous experiences, prediction of consequences, and help of others to recognize and interpret the situation. Less attention goes out to higher level critical thinking (i.e., moral awareness, integrating available information, and analyzing personal biases in the decision-making process). Thus, it seems that in these critical incidents, the servicemen react without giving room for thorough consideration and deliberation. Second, the number of deployments a serviceman experienced influences the perceived seriousness and harmfulness of the situation negatively in low-intense situations. Finally, and in line with earlier studies, the results indicate that the concept of moral intensity is formed out of three rather than the six dimensions originally proposed by Jones (1991). The implications of these findings are discussed.

KW - UT-Hybrid-D

U2 - 10.1177/0007650316680996

DO - 10.1177/0007650316680996

M3 - Article

VL - 58

SP - 749

EP - 778

JO - Business & society

JF - Business & society

SN - 0007-6503

IS - 4

ER -