Smart design rules for smart grids: analysing local smart grid development through an empirico-legal institutional lens

Imke Lammers, Michiel A. Heldeweg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

43 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: This article entails an innovative approach to smart grid technology implementation, as it connects governance research with legal analysis. We apply the empirico-legal ‘ILTIAD framework’, which combines Elinor Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework with institutional legal theory (ILT), to an empirical case study of a local smart grid project.

Methods: Empirical data were collected in an exploratory, descriptive example study of a single case, focusing on the Action Situation and interactions towards establishing a local Smart Grid. The case was chosen because of its complexity, following the ‘logic of intensity sampling’. Data triangulation took place combining participatory observation, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis.

Results: Through an exploratory case study, we showed how the ILTIAD framework can help reduce complexity in local decision-making processes on smart grid implementation, as it allows for analytical description and prescriptive design of local smart grid systems. In the analysis we addressed ownership arrangements and contracts and identified barriers and opportunities for realizing a local smart grid system. The design part includes a scenario which revealed the prescribed patterns of behaviour (liberties and abilities) and the consequential aspects that apply to each situation.

Conclusions: Analysing and designing normative alignment ex ante to the planning and implementation of a smart grid system provides clarity to stakeholders about their current opportunities. For this reason, the ILTIAD framework can be used as a design guideline for establishing new and integrated smart grid projects.
Original languageEnglish
Article number36
JournalEnergy, sustainability and society
Volume6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

Lenses
legal theory
empirical method
document analysis
triangulation
Triangulation
decision-making process
Decision making
stakeholder
governance
Sampling
scenario
Planning
planning
ability
interaction
interview
smart grid
ownership
legislation

Keywords

  • METIS-320121
  • IR-102801

Cite this

@article{c0561807d1704cb7afc226286978e49e,
title = "Smart design rules for smart grids: analysing local smart grid development through an empirico-legal institutional lens",
abstract = "Background: This article entails an innovative approach to smart grid technology implementation, as it connects governance research with legal analysis. We apply the empirico-legal ‘ILTIAD framework’, which combines Elinor Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework with institutional legal theory (ILT), to an empirical case study of a local smart grid project.Methods: Empirical data were collected in an exploratory, descriptive example study of a single case, focusing on the Action Situation and interactions towards establishing a local Smart Grid. The case was chosen because of its complexity, following the ‘logic of intensity sampling’. Data triangulation took place combining participatory observation, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis.Results: Through an exploratory case study, we showed how the ILTIAD framework can help reduce complexity in local decision-making processes on smart grid implementation, as it allows for analytical description and prescriptive design of local smart grid systems. In the analysis we addressed ownership arrangements and contracts and identified barriers and opportunities for realizing a local smart grid system. The design part includes a scenario which revealed the prescribed patterns of behaviour (liberties and abilities) and the consequential aspects that apply to each situation.Conclusions: Analysing and designing normative alignment ex ante to the planning and implementation of a smart grid system provides clarity to stakeholders about their current opportunities. For this reason, the ILTIAD framework can be used as a design guideline for establishing new and integrated smart grid projects.",
keywords = "METIS-320121, IR-102801",
author = "Imke Lammers and Heldeweg, {Michiel A.}",
note = "Open access",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1186/s13705-016-0102-z",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
journal = "Energy, sustainability and society",
issn = "2192-0567",
publisher = "Springer",

}

Smart design rules for smart grids : analysing local smart grid development through an empirico-legal institutional lens. / Lammers, Imke; Heldeweg, Michiel A.

In: Energy, sustainability and society, Vol. 6, 36, 2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Smart design rules for smart grids

T2 - analysing local smart grid development through an empirico-legal institutional lens

AU - Lammers, Imke

AU - Heldeweg, Michiel A.

N1 - Open access

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Background: This article entails an innovative approach to smart grid technology implementation, as it connects governance research with legal analysis. We apply the empirico-legal ‘ILTIAD framework’, which combines Elinor Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework with institutional legal theory (ILT), to an empirical case study of a local smart grid project.Methods: Empirical data were collected in an exploratory, descriptive example study of a single case, focusing on the Action Situation and interactions towards establishing a local Smart Grid. The case was chosen because of its complexity, following the ‘logic of intensity sampling’. Data triangulation took place combining participatory observation, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis.Results: Through an exploratory case study, we showed how the ILTIAD framework can help reduce complexity in local decision-making processes on smart grid implementation, as it allows for analytical description and prescriptive design of local smart grid systems. In the analysis we addressed ownership arrangements and contracts and identified barriers and opportunities for realizing a local smart grid system. The design part includes a scenario which revealed the prescribed patterns of behaviour (liberties and abilities) and the consequential aspects that apply to each situation.Conclusions: Analysing and designing normative alignment ex ante to the planning and implementation of a smart grid system provides clarity to stakeholders about their current opportunities. For this reason, the ILTIAD framework can be used as a design guideline for establishing new and integrated smart grid projects.

AB - Background: This article entails an innovative approach to smart grid technology implementation, as it connects governance research with legal analysis. We apply the empirico-legal ‘ILTIAD framework’, which combines Elinor Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework with institutional legal theory (ILT), to an empirical case study of a local smart grid project.Methods: Empirical data were collected in an exploratory, descriptive example study of a single case, focusing on the Action Situation and interactions towards establishing a local Smart Grid. The case was chosen because of its complexity, following the ‘logic of intensity sampling’. Data triangulation took place combining participatory observation, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis.Results: Through an exploratory case study, we showed how the ILTIAD framework can help reduce complexity in local decision-making processes on smart grid implementation, as it allows for analytical description and prescriptive design of local smart grid systems. In the analysis we addressed ownership arrangements and contracts and identified barriers and opportunities for realizing a local smart grid system. The design part includes a scenario which revealed the prescribed patterns of behaviour (liberties and abilities) and the consequential aspects that apply to each situation.Conclusions: Analysing and designing normative alignment ex ante to the planning and implementation of a smart grid system provides clarity to stakeholders about their current opportunities. For this reason, the ILTIAD framework can be used as a design guideline for establishing new and integrated smart grid projects.

KW - METIS-320121

KW - IR-102801

U2 - 10.1186/s13705-016-0102-z

DO - 10.1186/s13705-016-0102-z

M3 - Article

VL - 6

JO - Energy, sustainability and society

JF - Energy, sustainability and society

SN - 2192-0567

M1 - 36

ER -