The construction of new scientific norms for solving grand challenges: Reflections from the Norwegian Idélab research programme

Research output: Working paperProfessional

89 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

There is an increasing recognition that there are a class of problems which society must solve urgently in the 21st century if humanity is to survive into the 22nd, the so-called Grand Challenges. Science policy makers have been active in recognising these challenges and the attendant need to develop new multidisciplinary ways of working. But embracing multidisciplinarity is not a straightforward choice for scientists, who individually are strongly steered by norms and values inculcated through their past scientific experiences. In this paper, therefore, we ask whether new funding approaches can contribute to creating new ways of working by scientists towards challenge-driven research, specifically by changing scientists’ expectations and beliefs. We address this research question with reference to a single new experimental method, the ‘research sandpit’, implemented experimentally in a single national science system, Norway. We conclude that the sandpit approach appeared to shift research perceptions of individual scientists, particularly around long-term belief structures.
Original languageEnglish
Pages-
Number of pages28
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Publication series

NameCHEPS working paper
No.07
Volume2017

Fingerprint

science policy
Norway
funding
science
Values
experience
Society

Cite this

@techreport{f668569a201a4e8a90aa2f7c157d6a33,
title = "The construction of new scientific norms for solving grand challenges: Reflections from the Norwegian Id{\'e}lab research programme",
abstract = "There is an increasing recognition that there are a class of problems which society must solve urgently in the 21st century if humanity is to survive into the 22nd, the so-called Grand Challenges. Science policy makers have been active in recognising these challenges and the attendant need to develop new multidisciplinary ways of working. But embracing multidisciplinarity is not a straightforward choice for scientists, who individually are strongly steered by norms and values inculcated through their past scientific experiences. In this paper, therefore, we ask whether new funding approaches can contribute to creating new ways of working by scientists towards challenge-driven research, specifically by changing scientists’ expectations and beliefs. We address this research question with reference to a single new experimental method, the ‘research sandpit’, implemented experimentally in a single national science system, Norway. We conclude that the sandpit approach appeared to shift research perceptions of individual scientists, particularly around long-term belief structures.",
author = "Kate Maxwell and Benneworth, {Paul Stephen}",
year = "2017",
language = "English",
series = "CHEPS working paper",
number = "07",
pages = "--",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

The construction of new scientific norms for solving grand challenges : Reflections from the Norwegian Idélab research programme. / Maxwell, Kate; Benneworth, Paul Stephen.

2017. p. - (CHEPS working paper; Vol. 2017, No. 07).

Research output: Working paperProfessional

TY - UNPB

T1 - The construction of new scientific norms for solving grand challenges

T2 - Reflections from the Norwegian Idélab research programme

AU - Maxwell, Kate

AU - Benneworth, Paul Stephen

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - There is an increasing recognition that there are a class of problems which society must solve urgently in the 21st century if humanity is to survive into the 22nd, the so-called Grand Challenges. Science policy makers have been active in recognising these challenges and the attendant need to develop new multidisciplinary ways of working. But embracing multidisciplinarity is not a straightforward choice for scientists, who individually are strongly steered by norms and values inculcated through their past scientific experiences. In this paper, therefore, we ask whether new funding approaches can contribute to creating new ways of working by scientists towards challenge-driven research, specifically by changing scientists’ expectations and beliefs. We address this research question with reference to a single new experimental method, the ‘research sandpit’, implemented experimentally in a single national science system, Norway. We conclude that the sandpit approach appeared to shift research perceptions of individual scientists, particularly around long-term belief structures.

AB - There is an increasing recognition that there are a class of problems which society must solve urgently in the 21st century if humanity is to survive into the 22nd, the so-called Grand Challenges. Science policy makers have been active in recognising these challenges and the attendant need to develop new multidisciplinary ways of working. But embracing multidisciplinarity is not a straightforward choice for scientists, who individually are strongly steered by norms and values inculcated through their past scientific experiences. In this paper, therefore, we ask whether new funding approaches can contribute to creating new ways of working by scientists towards challenge-driven research, specifically by changing scientists’ expectations and beliefs. We address this research question with reference to a single new experimental method, the ‘research sandpit’, implemented experimentally in a single national science system, Norway. We conclude that the sandpit approach appeared to shift research perceptions of individual scientists, particularly around long-term belief structures.

M3 - Working paper

T3 - CHEPS working paper

SP - -

BT - The construction of new scientific norms for solving grand challenges

ER -