The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

This paper elaborates on the results of a multiple-case study of two distinct organisations: one in the private and the other in the public sector. We aimed to examine how new HRM policies were enacted in organisations where conventional HRM hiring routines were modified during the enactment process. Questions, how ostensive aspects of routines constrain and/or enable members in this process, and how ostensive aspects of routines are modified and evolve into new routines, guided our research. Results show that in the public organisation ostensive aspects indeed hamper the development of the new HRM routine, but organisational members are keen to make use of the constrictive aspects of routines to create a better fitting policy. In the private organisation we observed the opposite. Namely, that the lack of ostensive aspects of routines while implementing the new HRM routine, leads to a power play in which roles are defined, responsibilities shifted, and finally lead to novel ostensive aspects that inspire the new routine to work. Our findings indicate that members actively change ostensive aspects of routines by taking initiative, claiming power segments, and behaving proactively to enact the policy, but in different ways depending on how the existing routine was performed in both organisations in the past.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 7 Jul 2017
Event33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017: The good organization: aspirations, interventions, struggles - Copenhagen Business School, Copenhagen, Denmark
Duration: 6 Jul 20178 Jul 2017
Conference number: 33
https://www.egosnet.org/2017_copenhagen/general_theme

Conference

Conference33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017
Abbreviated titleEGOS
CountryDenmark
CityCopenhagen
Period6/07/178/07/17
Internet address

Fingerprint

hiring
public sector
responsibility
lack

Cite this

van Mierlo, J., Bondarouk, T., & Loohuis, R. P. A. (2017). The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects. Paper presented at 33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark.
@conference{5012532331614f1fb646966560dd2b4d,
title = "The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects",
abstract = "This paper elaborates on the results of a multiple-case study of two distinct organisations: one in the private and the other in the public sector. We aimed to examine how new HRM policies were enacted in organisations where conventional HRM hiring routines were modified during the enactment process. Questions, how ostensive aspects of routines constrain and/or enable members in this process, and how ostensive aspects of routines are modified and evolve into new routines, guided our research. Results show that in the public organisation ostensive aspects indeed hamper the development of the new HRM routine, but organisational members are keen to make use of the constrictive aspects of routines to create a better fitting policy. In the private organisation we observed the opposite. Namely, that the lack of ostensive aspects of routines while implementing the new HRM routine, leads to a power play in which roles are defined, responsibilities shifted, and finally lead to novel ostensive aspects that inspire the new routine to work. Our findings indicate that members actively change ostensive aspects of routines by taking initiative, claiming power segments, and behaving proactively to enact the policy, but in different ways depending on how the existing routine was performed in both organisations in the past.",
author = "{van Mierlo}, Jorrit and Tatiana Bondarouk and Loohuis, {Raymond Petrus Antonius}",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "7",
language = "English",
note = "33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017 : The good organization: aspirations, interventions, struggles, EGOS ; Conference date: 06-07-2017 Through 08-07-2017",
url = "https://www.egosnet.org/2017_copenhagen/general_theme",

}

van Mierlo, J, Bondarouk, T & Loohuis, RPA 2017, 'The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects' Paper presented at 33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark, 6/07/17 - 8/07/17, .

The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects. / van Mierlo, Jorrit ; Bondarouk, Tatiana ; Loohuis, Raymond Petrus Antonius.

2017. Paper presented at 33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperAcademicpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects

AU - van Mierlo, Jorrit

AU - Bondarouk, Tatiana

AU - Loohuis, Raymond Petrus Antonius

PY - 2017/7/7

Y1 - 2017/7/7

N2 - This paper elaborates on the results of a multiple-case study of two distinct organisations: one in the private and the other in the public sector. We aimed to examine how new HRM policies were enacted in organisations where conventional HRM hiring routines were modified during the enactment process. Questions, how ostensive aspects of routines constrain and/or enable members in this process, and how ostensive aspects of routines are modified and evolve into new routines, guided our research. Results show that in the public organisation ostensive aspects indeed hamper the development of the new HRM routine, but organisational members are keen to make use of the constrictive aspects of routines to create a better fitting policy. In the private organisation we observed the opposite. Namely, that the lack of ostensive aspects of routines while implementing the new HRM routine, leads to a power play in which roles are defined, responsibilities shifted, and finally lead to novel ostensive aspects that inspire the new routine to work. Our findings indicate that members actively change ostensive aspects of routines by taking initiative, claiming power segments, and behaving proactively to enact the policy, but in different ways depending on how the existing routine was performed in both organisations in the past.

AB - This paper elaborates on the results of a multiple-case study of two distinct organisations: one in the private and the other in the public sector. We aimed to examine how new HRM policies were enacted in organisations where conventional HRM hiring routines were modified during the enactment process. Questions, how ostensive aspects of routines constrain and/or enable members in this process, and how ostensive aspects of routines are modified and evolve into new routines, guided our research. Results show that in the public organisation ostensive aspects indeed hamper the development of the new HRM routine, but organisational members are keen to make use of the constrictive aspects of routines to create a better fitting policy. In the private organisation we observed the opposite. Namely, that the lack of ostensive aspects of routines while implementing the new HRM routine, leads to a power play in which roles are defined, responsibilities shifted, and finally lead to novel ostensive aspects that inspire the new routine to work. Our findings indicate that members actively change ostensive aspects of routines by taking initiative, claiming power segments, and behaving proactively to enact the policy, but in different ways depending on how the existing routine was performed in both organisations in the past.

M3 - Paper

ER -

van Mierlo J, Bondarouk T, Loohuis RPA. The emergence of a new HRM routine: Balancing between ostensive and performative aspects. 2017. Paper presented at 33rd EGOS Colloquium 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark.