Towards assimilation of crowdsourced observations for different levels of citizen engagement: the flood event of 2013 in the Bacchiglione catchment

Maurizio Mazzoleni (Corresponding Author), Vivian Juliette Cortes Arevalo, Uta Wehn, Leonardo Alfonso, Daniele Norbiato, Martina Monego, Michele Ferri, Dimitri P. Solomatine

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

64 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Accurate flood predictions are essential to reduce the risk and damages over large urbanized areas. To improve prediction capabilities, hydrological measurements derived by traditional physical sensors are integrated in real-time within mathematic models. Recently, traditional sensors are complemented with low-cost social sensors. However, measurements derived by social sensors (i.e. crowdsourced observations) can be more spatially distributed but less accurate. In this study, we assess the usefulness for model performance of assimilating crowdsourced observations from a heterogeneous network of static physical, static social and dynamic social sensors. We assess potential effects on the model predictions to the extreme flood event occurred in the Bacchiglione catchment on May 2013. Flood predictions are estimated at the target point of Ponte degli Angeli (Vicenza), outlet of the Bacchiglione catchment, by means of a semi-distributed hydrological model. The contribution of the upstream sub-catchment is calculated using a conceptual hydrological model. The flow is propagated along the river reach using a hydraulic model. In both models, a Kalman filter is implemented to assimilate the real-time crowdsourced observations. We synthetically derived crowdsourced observations for either static social or dynamic social sensors because crowdsourced measures were not available. We consider three sets of experiments: 1) only physical sensors are available; 2) probability of receiving crowdsourced observations and 3) realistic scenario of citizen engagement based on population distribution. The results demonstrated the importance of integrating crowdsourced observations. Observations from upstream sub-catchments assimilated into the hydrological model ensures high model performance for high lead time values. Observations next to the outlet of the catchments provide good results for short lead times. Furthermore, citizen engagement level scenarios moved by a feeling of belonging to a community of friends indicated flood prediction improvements when such small communities are located upstream a particular target point. Effective communication and feedback is required between water authorities and
citizens to ensure minimum engagement levels and to minimize the intrinsic low-variable accuracy of crowdsourced observations
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)391-416
Number of pages40
JournalHydrology and earth system sciences discussions
Volume22
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 Jan 2018

Fingerprint

Catchments
catchment
sensor
Sensors
prediction
Population distribution
Hydraulic models
citizen
assimilation
Heterogeneous networks
population distribution
Kalman filters
mathematics
Kalman filter
Rivers
Feedback
communication
hydraulics
Communication
damage

Cite this

Mazzoleni, Maurizio ; Cortes Arevalo, Vivian Juliette ; Wehn, Uta ; Alfonso, Leonardo ; Norbiato, Daniele ; Monego, Martina ; Ferri, Michele ; Solomatine, Dimitri P. / Towards assimilation of crowdsourced observations for different levels of citizen engagement : the flood event of 2013 in the Bacchiglione catchment. In: Hydrology and earth system sciences discussions. 2018 ; Vol. 22. pp. 391-416.
@article{2a3135d0e1574bf48b22b45c78543107,
title = "Towards assimilation of crowdsourced observations for different levels of citizen engagement: the flood event of 2013 in the Bacchiglione catchment",
abstract = "Accurate flood predictions are essential to reduce the risk and damages over large urbanized areas. To improve prediction capabilities, hydrological measurements derived by traditional physical sensors are integrated in real-time within mathematic models. Recently, traditional sensors are complemented with low-cost social sensors. However, measurements derived by social sensors (i.e. crowdsourced observations) can be more spatially distributed but less accurate. In this study, we assess the usefulness for model performance of assimilating crowdsourced observations from a heterogeneous network of static physical, static social and dynamic social sensors. We assess potential effects on the model predictions to the extreme flood event occurred in the Bacchiglione catchment on May 2013. Flood predictions are estimated at the target point of Ponte degli Angeli (Vicenza), outlet of the Bacchiglione catchment, by means of a semi-distributed hydrological model. The contribution of the upstream sub-catchment is calculated using a conceptual hydrological model. The flow is propagated along the river reach using a hydraulic model. In both models, a Kalman filter is implemented to assimilate the real-time crowdsourced observations. We synthetically derived crowdsourced observations for either static social or dynamic social sensors because crowdsourced measures were not available. We consider three sets of experiments: 1) only physical sensors are available; 2) probability of receiving crowdsourced observations and 3) realistic scenario of citizen engagement based on population distribution. The results demonstrated the importance of integrating crowdsourced observations. Observations from upstream sub-catchments assimilated into the hydrological model ensures high model performance for high lead time values. Observations next to the outlet of the catchments provide good results for short lead times. Furthermore, citizen engagement level scenarios moved by a feeling of belonging to a community of friends indicated flood prediction improvements when such small communities are located upstream a particular target point. Effective communication and feedback is required between water authorities andcitizens to ensure minimum engagement levels and to minimize the intrinsic low-variable accuracy of crowdsourced observations",
author = "Maurizio Mazzoleni and {Cortes Arevalo}, {Vivian Juliette} and Uta Wehn and Leonardo Alfonso and Daniele Norbiato and Martina Monego and Michele Ferri and Solomatine, {Dimitri P.}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "17",
doi = "10.5194/hess-2017-59",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "391--416",
journal = "Hydrology and earth system sciences discussions",
issn = "1812-2108",
publisher = "Copernicus",

}

Towards assimilation of crowdsourced observations for different levels of citizen engagement : the flood event of 2013 in the Bacchiglione catchment. / Mazzoleni, Maurizio (Corresponding Author); Cortes Arevalo, Vivian Juliette; Wehn, Uta; Alfonso, Leonardo; Norbiato, Daniele; Monego, Martina; Ferri, Michele; Solomatine, Dimitri P.

In: Hydrology and earth system sciences discussions, Vol. 22, 17.01.2018, p. 391-416.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards assimilation of crowdsourced observations for different levels of citizen engagement

T2 - the flood event of 2013 in the Bacchiglione catchment

AU - Mazzoleni, Maurizio

AU - Cortes Arevalo, Vivian Juliette

AU - Wehn, Uta

AU - Alfonso, Leonardo

AU - Norbiato, Daniele

AU - Monego, Martina

AU - Ferri, Michele

AU - Solomatine, Dimitri P.

PY - 2018/1/17

Y1 - 2018/1/17

N2 - Accurate flood predictions are essential to reduce the risk and damages over large urbanized areas. To improve prediction capabilities, hydrological measurements derived by traditional physical sensors are integrated in real-time within mathematic models. Recently, traditional sensors are complemented with low-cost social sensors. However, measurements derived by social sensors (i.e. crowdsourced observations) can be more spatially distributed but less accurate. In this study, we assess the usefulness for model performance of assimilating crowdsourced observations from a heterogeneous network of static physical, static social and dynamic social sensors. We assess potential effects on the model predictions to the extreme flood event occurred in the Bacchiglione catchment on May 2013. Flood predictions are estimated at the target point of Ponte degli Angeli (Vicenza), outlet of the Bacchiglione catchment, by means of a semi-distributed hydrological model. The contribution of the upstream sub-catchment is calculated using a conceptual hydrological model. The flow is propagated along the river reach using a hydraulic model. In both models, a Kalman filter is implemented to assimilate the real-time crowdsourced observations. We synthetically derived crowdsourced observations for either static social or dynamic social sensors because crowdsourced measures were not available. We consider three sets of experiments: 1) only physical sensors are available; 2) probability of receiving crowdsourced observations and 3) realistic scenario of citizen engagement based on population distribution. The results demonstrated the importance of integrating crowdsourced observations. Observations from upstream sub-catchments assimilated into the hydrological model ensures high model performance for high lead time values. Observations next to the outlet of the catchments provide good results for short lead times. Furthermore, citizen engagement level scenarios moved by a feeling of belonging to a community of friends indicated flood prediction improvements when such small communities are located upstream a particular target point. Effective communication and feedback is required between water authorities andcitizens to ensure minimum engagement levels and to minimize the intrinsic low-variable accuracy of crowdsourced observations

AB - Accurate flood predictions are essential to reduce the risk and damages over large urbanized areas. To improve prediction capabilities, hydrological measurements derived by traditional physical sensors are integrated in real-time within mathematic models. Recently, traditional sensors are complemented with low-cost social sensors. However, measurements derived by social sensors (i.e. crowdsourced observations) can be more spatially distributed but less accurate. In this study, we assess the usefulness for model performance of assimilating crowdsourced observations from a heterogeneous network of static physical, static social and dynamic social sensors. We assess potential effects on the model predictions to the extreme flood event occurred in the Bacchiglione catchment on May 2013. Flood predictions are estimated at the target point of Ponte degli Angeli (Vicenza), outlet of the Bacchiglione catchment, by means of a semi-distributed hydrological model. The contribution of the upstream sub-catchment is calculated using a conceptual hydrological model. The flow is propagated along the river reach using a hydraulic model. In both models, a Kalman filter is implemented to assimilate the real-time crowdsourced observations. We synthetically derived crowdsourced observations for either static social or dynamic social sensors because crowdsourced measures were not available. We consider three sets of experiments: 1) only physical sensors are available; 2) probability of receiving crowdsourced observations and 3) realistic scenario of citizen engagement based on population distribution. The results demonstrated the importance of integrating crowdsourced observations. Observations from upstream sub-catchments assimilated into the hydrological model ensures high model performance for high lead time values. Observations next to the outlet of the catchments provide good results for short lead times. Furthermore, citizen engagement level scenarios moved by a feeling of belonging to a community of friends indicated flood prediction improvements when such small communities are located upstream a particular target point. Effective communication and feedback is required between water authorities andcitizens to ensure minimum engagement levels and to minimize the intrinsic low-variable accuracy of crowdsourced observations

UR - https://www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci-discuss.net/hess-2017-59/

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/towards-assimilation-crowdsourced-observations-different-levels-citizen-engagement-flood-event-2013

U2 - 10.5194/hess-2017-59

DO - 10.5194/hess-2017-59

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 391

EP - 416

JO - Hydrology and earth system sciences discussions

JF - Hydrology and earth system sciences discussions

SN - 1812-2108

ER -