Understanding actor perspectives regarding challenges for integrated river basin management

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

    1 Citation (Scopus)
    34 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    Integrated river basin management increases technical as well as management and governance complexity. In this multidisciplinary setting, actors, from their different backgrounds, frame both issues and solutions differently. To resolve conflicts, it is important to recognize – and to not ignore – the existence of contending social framings. A better understanding is needed of how actors frame issues and solutions in integrated river basin management. To gain this better understanding, semi-structured interviews were conducted with Dutch river basin management actors following Sense-making methodology. Three challenges were identified where respondents framed both the issue and solution differently: (1) creating flexibility in a controlled river system; (2) sustaining the integrated approach in the maintenance of floodplains; and (3) formulating future river basin management policies to adapt to climate change. Cultural Theory was subsequently used to analyse how respondents construct perspectives towards these challenges. The analysis showed how actors use different rationalities in constructing these perspectives. As an implication, it is important for actors to recognize and acknowledge these perspectives in integrated river basin management decision-making. New tools, embedded in learning environments, are needed to facilitate exchanging and understanding actors’ perspectives.
    Original languageEnglish
    Number of pages14
    JournalInternational journal of river basin management
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2018

    Fingerprint

    basin management
    river basin
    integrated approach
    river system
    floodplain
    learning
    decision making
    climate change
    methodology

    Keywords

    • UT-Hybrid-D
    • cultural theory
    • floodplain management
    • frames
    • learning environment
    • sense-making
    • the Netherlands
    • Integrated river basin management

    Cite this

    @article{7a4f725ad4e84b018e0b90714ff0651f,
    title = "Understanding actor perspectives regarding challenges for integrated river basin management",
    abstract = "Integrated river basin management increases technical as well as management and governance complexity. In this multidisciplinary setting, actors, from their different backgrounds, frame both issues and solutions differently. To resolve conflicts, it is important to recognize – and to not ignore – the existence of contending social framings. A better understanding is needed of how actors frame issues and solutions in integrated river basin management. To gain this better understanding, semi-structured interviews were conducted with Dutch river basin management actors following Sense-making methodology. Three challenges were identified where respondents framed both the issue and solution differently: (1) creating flexibility in a controlled river system; (2) sustaining the integrated approach in the maintenance of floodplains; and (3) formulating future river basin management policies to adapt to climate change. Cultural Theory was subsequently used to analyse how respondents construct perspectives towards these challenges. The analysis showed how actors use different rationalities in constructing these perspectives. As an implication, it is important for actors to recognize and acknowledge these perspectives in integrated river basin management decision-making. New tools, embedded in learning environments, are needed to facilitate exchanging and understanding actors’ perspectives.",
    keywords = "UT-Hybrid-D, cultural theory, floodplain management, frames, learning environment, sense-making, the Netherlands, Integrated river basin management",
    author = "{den Haan}, Robert-Jan and Fliervoet, {Jan M.} and {van der Voort}, {Mascha C.} and {Cortes Arevalo}, {Vivian Juliette} and Hulscher, {Suzanne J.M.H.}",
    note = "Taylor & Francis deal",
    year = "2018",
    doi = "10.1080/15715124.2018.1503186",
    language = "English",
    journal = "International journal of river basin management",
    issn = "1571-5124",
    publisher = "Taylor & Francis",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Understanding actor perspectives regarding challenges for integrated river basin management

    AU - den Haan, Robert-Jan

    AU - Fliervoet, Jan M.

    AU - van der Voort, Mascha C.

    AU - Cortes Arevalo, Vivian Juliette

    AU - Hulscher, Suzanne J.M.H.

    N1 - Taylor & Francis deal

    PY - 2018

    Y1 - 2018

    N2 - Integrated river basin management increases technical as well as management and governance complexity. In this multidisciplinary setting, actors, from their different backgrounds, frame both issues and solutions differently. To resolve conflicts, it is important to recognize – and to not ignore – the existence of contending social framings. A better understanding is needed of how actors frame issues and solutions in integrated river basin management. To gain this better understanding, semi-structured interviews were conducted with Dutch river basin management actors following Sense-making methodology. Three challenges were identified where respondents framed both the issue and solution differently: (1) creating flexibility in a controlled river system; (2) sustaining the integrated approach in the maintenance of floodplains; and (3) formulating future river basin management policies to adapt to climate change. Cultural Theory was subsequently used to analyse how respondents construct perspectives towards these challenges. The analysis showed how actors use different rationalities in constructing these perspectives. As an implication, it is important for actors to recognize and acknowledge these perspectives in integrated river basin management decision-making. New tools, embedded in learning environments, are needed to facilitate exchanging and understanding actors’ perspectives.

    AB - Integrated river basin management increases technical as well as management and governance complexity. In this multidisciplinary setting, actors, from their different backgrounds, frame both issues and solutions differently. To resolve conflicts, it is important to recognize – and to not ignore – the existence of contending social framings. A better understanding is needed of how actors frame issues and solutions in integrated river basin management. To gain this better understanding, semi-structured interviews were conducted with Dutch river basin management actors following Sense-making methodology. Three challenges were identified where respondents framed both the issue and solution differently: (1) creating flexibility in a controlled river system; (2) sustaining the integrated approach in the maintenance of floodplains; and (3) formulating future river basin management policies to adapt to climate change. Cultural Theory was subsequently used to analyse how respondents construct perspectives towards these challenges. The analysis showed how actors use different rationalities in constructing these perspectives. As an implication, it is important for actors to recognize and acknowledge these perspectives in integrated river basin management decision-making. New tools, embedded in learning environments, are needed to facilitate exchanging and understanding actors’ perspectives.

    KW - UT-Hybrid-D

    KW - cultural theory

    KW - floodplain management

    KW - frames

    KW - learning environment

    KW - sense-making

    KW - the Netherlands

    KW - Integrated river basin management

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85051984544&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/15715124.2018.1503186

    DO - 10.1080/15715124.2018.1503186

    M3 - Article

    JO - International journal of river basin management

    JF - International journal of river basin management

    SN - 1571-5124

    ER -