Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre

Rolf E. Egberink, Danique Hesselink, Maarten J. IJzerman, Arie B. van Vugt, Carine J.M. Doggen

Research output: Contribution to conferencePosterOther research output

8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Introduction: Trauma team activation is a kind of triage the staff of an Emergency Department (ED) exerts to determine whether a trauma team needs to be activated for severely injured patients and in what composition the team needs to be deployed. It is a difficult decision-making process which is often performed by ED nurses and influenced by several factors. Objective: Understand the trauma team activation decision-making process at a Dutch ED and obtain insight in the importance of several factors of influence according to ED nurses. Methods: Cross-sectional fractional factorial design. Patient factors (attributes) were identified by literature review and discussed with trauma experts. SPSS® Orthoplan was used to generate a fraction (n=25) of all possible alternative scenarios (n=2304), that consisted of combinations of the attribute levels. Scenarios were presented to 44 ED nurses at a level I trauma centre using a questionnaire with a total of 26 clinical vignettes. ED nurses were asked to rank the attributes according to their perceived importance. Results: 27 ED nurses (61%) completed the questionnaire. The number of team activations per respondent varied for the possible teams. After normalizing the level mean rank scores, the level Airway-Breathing unstable was the most important level for trauma team activation based on the relative rank sum weight (0.115), followed by Mechanism of injury Fall of height >5m (0.171) and Airway-Breathing Intubation (0.172). There was no difference in attribute mean rank scores between two groups of ED nurses, stratified for years of work experience. The ICC for the different levels occurring in the three duplicate vignettes varied. Discussion: We observed variation in decisions for trauma team activation and in consistency of the rank scores among the ED nurses under study. This implies that a decision support system could improve uniformity in the trauma team activation decision-making process.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages1
Publication statusPublished - 12 Sep 2013
EventWetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013 - Enschede, Netherlands
Duration: 12 Sep 201312 Sep 2013

Conference

ConferenceWetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013
CountryNetherlands
CityEnschede
Period12/09/1312/09/13

Fingerprint

Trauma Centers
Hospital Emergency Service
Decision Making
Emergencies
Nurses
Wounds and Injuries
Respiration
Triage
Intubation
Weights and Measures

Keywords

  • METIS-297355
  • IR-87063

Cite this

Egberink, R. E., Hesselink, D., IJzerman, M. J., van Vugt, A. B., & Doggen, C. J. M. (2013). Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre. Poster session presented at Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013, Enschede, Netherlands.
Egberink, Rolf E. ; Hesselink, Danique ; IJzerman, Maarten J. ; van Vugt, Arie B. ; Doggen, Carine J.M. / Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre. Poster session presented at Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013, Enschede, Netherlands.1 p.
@conference{d648396321574921b02f0d7f8971583a,
title = "Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre",
abstract = "Introduction: Trauma team activation is a kind of triage the staff of an Emergency Department (ED) exerts to determine whether a trauma team needs to be activated for severely injured patients and in what composition the team needs to be deployed. It is a difficult decision-making process which is often performed by ED nurses and influenced by several factors. Objective: Understand the trauma team activation decision-making process at a Dutch ED and obtain insight in the importance of several factors of influence according to ED nurses. Methods: Cross-sectional fractional factorial design. Patient factors (attributes) were identified by literature review and discussed with trauma experts. SPSS{\circledR} Orthoplan was used to generate a fraction (n=25) of all possible alternative scenarios (n=2304), that consisted of combinations of the attribute levels. Scenarios were presented to 44 ED nurses at a level I trauma centre using a questionnaire with a total of 26 clinical vignettes. ED nurses were asked to rank the attributes according to their perceived importance. Results: 27 ED nurses (61{\%}) completed the questionnaire. The number of team activations per respondent varied for the possible teams. After normalizing the level mean rank scores, the level Airway-Breathing unstable was the most important level for trauma team activation based on the relative rank sum weight (0.115), followed by Mechanism of injury Fall of height >5m (0.171) and Airway-Breathing Intubation (0.172). There was no difference in attribute mean rank scores between two groups of ED nurses, stratified for years of work experience. The ICC for the different levels occurring in the three duplicate vignettes varied. Discussion: We observed variation in decisions for trauma team activation and in consistency of the rank scores among the ED nurses under study. This implies that a decision support system could improve uniformity in the trauma team activation decision-making process.",
keywords = "METIS-297355, IR-87063",
author = "Egberink, {Rolf E.} and Danique Hesselink and IJzerman, {Maarten J.} and {van Vugt}, {Arie B.} and Doggen, {Carine J.M.}",
year = "2013",
month = "9",
day = "12",
language = "English",
note = "Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013 ; Conference date: 12-09-2013 Through 12-09-2013",

}

Egberink, RE, Hesselink, D, IJzerman, MJ, van Vugt, AB & Doggen, CJM 2013, 'Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre' Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013, Enschede, Netherlands, 12/09/13 - 12/09/13, .

Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre. / Egberink, Rolf E.; Hesselink, Danique; IJzerman, Maarten J.; van Vugt, Arie B.; Doggen, Carine J.M.

2013. Poster session presented at Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013, Enschede, Netherlands.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePosterOther research output

TY - CONF

T1 - Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre

AU - Egberink, Rolf E.

AU - Hesselink, Danique

AU - IJzerman, Maarten J.

AU - van Vugt, Arie B.

AU - Doggen, Carine J.M.

PY - 2013/9/12

Y1 - 2013/9/12

N2 - Introduction: Trauma team activation is a kind of triage the staff of an Emergency Department (ED) exerts to determine whether a trauma team needs to be activated for severely injured patients and in what composition the team needs to be deployed. It is a difficult decision-making process which is often performed by ED nurses and influenced by several factors. Objective: Understand the trauma team activation decision-making process at a Dutch ED and obtain insight in the importance of several factors of influence according to ED nurses. Methods: Cross-sectional fractional factorial design. Patient factors (attributes) were identified by literature review and discussed with trauma experts. SPSS® Orthoplan was used to generate a fraction (n=25) of all possible alternative scenarios (n=2304), that consisted of combinations of the attribute levels. Scenarios were presented to 44 ED nurses at a level I trauma centre using a questionnaire with a total of 26 clinical vignettes. ED nurses were asked to rank the attributes according to their perceived importance. Results: 27 ED nurses (61%) completed the questionnaire. The number of team activations per respondent varied for the possible teams. After normalizing the level mean rank scores, the level Airway-Breathing unstable was the most important level for trauma team activation based on the relative rank sum weight (0.115), followed by Mechanism of injury Fall of height >5m (0.171) and Airway-Breathing Intubation (0.172). There was no difference in attribute mean rank scores between two groups of ED nurses, stratified for years of work experience. The ICC for the different levels occurring in the three duplicate vignettes varied. Discussion: We observed variation in decisions for trauma team activation and in consistency of the rank scores among the ED nurses under study. This implies that a decision support system could improve uniformity in the trauma team activation decision-making process.

AB - Introduction: Trauma team activation is a kind of triage the staff of an Emergency Department (ED) exerts to determine whether a trauma team needs to be activated for severely injured patients and in what composition the team needs to be deployed. It is a difficult decision-making process which is often performed by ED nurses and influenced by several factors. Objective: Understand the trauma team activation decision-making process at a Dutch ED and obtain insight in the importance of several factors of influence according to ED nurses. Methods: Cross-sectional fractional factorial design. Patient factors (attributes) were identified by literature review and discussed with trauma experts. SPSS® Orthoplan was used to generate a fraction (n=25) of all possible alternative scenarios (n=2304), that consisted of combinations of the attribute levels. Scenarios were presented to 44 ED nurses at a level I trauma centre using a questionnaire with a total of 26 clinical vignettes. ED nurses were asked to rank the attributes according to their perceived importance. Results: 27 ED nurses (61%) completed the questionnaire. The number of team activations per respondent varied for the possible teams. After normalizing the level mean rank scores, the level Airway-Breathing unstable was the most important level for trauma team activation based on the relative rank sum weight (0.115), followed by Mechanism of injury Fall of height >5m (0.171) and Airway-Breathing Intubation (0.172). There was no difference in attribute mean rank scores between two groups of ED nurses, stratified for years of work experience. The ICC for the different levels occurring in the three duplicate vignettes varied. Discussion: We observed variation in decisions for trauma team activation and in consistency of the rank scores among the ED nurses under study. This implies that a decision support system could improve uniformity in the trauma team activation decision-making process.

KW - METIS-297355

KW - IR-87063

M3 - Poster

ER -

Egberink RE, Hesselink D, IJzerman MJ, van Vugt AB, Doggen CJM. Variation in decision-making in trauma team activation by emergency nurses at a Dutch level 1 trauma centre. 2013. Poster session presented at Wetenschapsdag Medisch Spectrum Twente 2013, Enschede, Netherlands.